What Are the Best Cheap Cat Toys?

HARTZ Just For Cats Toy
  • Keep your playful cat captivated for hours with a combo of Paw some toys
  • Lightweight toys are purrfect for your cat to carry, toss and bat
  • Exercise your cat's natural instincts to explore and thrive in the world around them with toys that stimulate all of their natural play needs

What are the Benefits of Buying Cheap Cat Toys?

Buying cheap cat toys is easy on the pocket and allows buying multiple toys. Here are some of the benefits of cheap cat toys:

  • Saves Money: The most obvious benefit to buying cheap cat toys is that they will save you money. This often comes with a trade-off of quality, but the good news is you can buy more when your cat is done with them.
  • Prey Drive: Cats have a high prey drive that remains with them throughout their life. Stimulating this instinct can help alleviate destructive behavior and help your cat to feel less stressed or anxious.
  • Health Boost: Pet toys like laser pointers, teaser wand toys, puzzle toys, and scratching posts help to stimulate your cat’s brain and encourage them to exercise.

The Best Cheap Cat Toys Reviewed

Cheap cat toys come in many designs. To help owners find the right match for their pets, we have reviewed some of the best cheap cat toys on Amazon and Chewy.

HARTZ Just For Cats Toy

HARTZ Just For Cats Toy

Get it on Amazon          Get it on Chewy

Price: $6.33

Toy Type: Balls, Plushies, Wand & Pom Poms

Pet: Cats

Lifestage: Cats of all ages

Recommended Uses: To enrich your cat’s life offer them a selection of toys. Replace the toy when it is worn out or when your cat loses interest and replace it with a new toy to revive its interest in playing.

Material: Plastic; Cotton; Catnip

Summary: This assortment of toys from Hartz includes 13 toys in total. Everything from a teaser toy to plush toys and a catnip fish cat toy is included to entice all of your cat’s hunting and playing instincts. The variety of items in this pack allows cat owners to provide their feline friends with a wide variety of playing options to enrich your cat’s life from all angles.

Your cat has tons of options in this bag. Plastic ball cat toys provide swatting and batting practice as they chase it across the floor to improve their paw coordination. A catnip toy is included to offer cats an enhanced good time, and plush mouse cat toys mimic a cat’s prey as they carry it around. No matter what your cat’s preferred style of play is, there is something for them in this variety pack.

Pros
  • Assortment of toys
  • Lightweight and easy for your cat to carry
  • Exercises your cat’s natural hunting instincts
  • Safe for cats of all ages
  • Perfect for independent play
Cons
  • Can pose a choking hazard
  • The teaser wand leaves something to be desired

Customer Reviews: Over 90% of reviewers liked this toy pack. The variety gave their cats plenty of things to keep them occupied, and the balls were sturdy when intensely batted around during high-energy play sessions. Their cats had plenty of stimulation, and these customers liked the price as well.

Critical reviews only account for 2% of total reviews, but these folks were mostly concerned about the quality of the toys. They said the hair on the furballs came off, and the eyes were easy to remove from most toys.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving HARTZ Just For Cats Toy an overall 9/10-star rating. The breakdown of our ratings is below:

  • Pet Suitability (8/10): There are some choking hazards on the mouse toys and bell toys.
  • Material Quality (7/10): The plastic toys were sturdy, but the plush toys have hair that easily comes off, and the catnip didn’t last long.
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): Priced at just over 50 cents per toy, this is a fantastic bang for your dollar.
  • Customer Feedback (10/10): Nearly 7,500 reviews give this toy set an average rating of 4.7 stars, which is high for an average rating.  
  • Care and Cleanability (8/10): Most of the toys in this pack do not need care or cleaning, and the plush toys can be hand-washed.
  • Product Variety (10/10): There is something in this pack for every cat’s playing style.

SmartyKat Skitter Critters Catnip Cat Toys

SmartyKat Skitter Critters Catnip Cat Toys

Get it on Amazon          Get it on Chewy

Price: $2.08

Toy Type: Plush catnip mice

Pet: Cats

Lifestage: Cats of all ages

Recommended Uses: Offer your cat these toys to provide mental and physical stimulation. These are great after mealtime or when your cat is going to be left alone for an extended period of time.

Material: Cotton

Summary: Infused with 100% pesticide-free, chemical-free catnip, this toy is made to keep your cat’s attention. Three mice come in this package, and each is made in China to meet the United States child toy safety standards. It is the second best-selling cat toy on Amazon thanks, in part, to the low price tag.

The plush construction of this toy is made of cotton sponge that keeps its shape even after intense biting. The lifelike size and shape of the toy stimulate a cat’s instincts to hunt and pounce, and this also makes the toy easy for your cat to carry around. Floppy ears and long tails are included in the design to help your cat feel closer to its wild side as they practice hunting and playing.

Pros
  • Same size as real mice
  • Three come in a package
  • 100% chemical-free and pesticide-free catnip
  • Made to meet child safety standards
  • Stimulates a cat’s instincts
Cons
  • Made in China
  • The tails can present a choking hazard

Customer Reviews: Nearly 34,000 reviews have been written about these mice toys, and the vast majority of them are raving about their high quality. These people have cats who love the toys, and numerous reviews mention how their cats carry the toys everywhere and seem to love them even after the catnip wears out.

The most common complaint from low-rated reviews is that their cats quickly tore up the toys or their cats weren’t interested in the toy at all.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving SmartyKat Skitter Critters Catnip Cat Toys an overall 9/10-star rating. The breakdown of our ratings is below:

  • Pet Suitability (9/10): The lifelike size and shape of the toys, as well as the catnip infusion, make them fantastic for cats.
  • Material Quality (10/10): The catnip is made without harsh chemicals and pesticides, and the toy is made to meet child safety standards.
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): This is at a price point anyone can afford.
  • Customer Feedback (10/10): Almost 34,000 reviews on Amazon give this toy set a high average rating of 4.7 stars. 
  • Care and Cleanability (8/10): The mice are hand washable.
  • Product Variety (9/10): There are three mice in this package, but each is the same design but with varying colors.

Ailuki Assorted Catnip Toy Set

Ailuki Assorted Catnip Toy Set

Get it on Amazon

Price: $13.99

Toy Type: Balls, Feathers, Teasers, Tunnels

Pet: Cats

Lifestage: Cats of all ages

Recommended Uses: When your cat is bored, offer them a variety of toys. This can be one toy or multiple. Put away toys your cat does not use, and when their preferred toys are worn out or lost, replace them with new toys. Watch out for loose or broken pieces that could pose a choking hazard.

Material: Cotton; Plastic; Feather

Summary: An assortment of toys can be necessary to support your cat’s development as much as possible. Variety packs like this help cat owners to do that at one low price. The toys in this set include teaser wands, catnip toys, and bells and balls that encourage your cat to play and practice its hunting and life skills.

A cat tunnel with hanging ball cat toys and a long cat teaser wand are the most notable toys in this set. These are complemented by feather toys and feather mice that encourage batting and pawing. Crinkle balls and a feather wand help to round off the variety pack and offer your cat another way to exercise their instincts on a daily basis.

Pros
  • Large assortment of toys
  • Includes catnip and catnip toys
  • Helps to improve all aspects of your cat’s well being
  • Made with premium materials for higher quality
  • The variety of toys helps to reduce your cat’s stress and anxiety
Cons
  • Some of the toys feel cheap
  • Some of the toys require human interaction to play with

Customer Reviews: Most pet owners were happy with the variety this package offered and said the quality was adequate for their cats. The price was great, and these people had cats who loved the toys given to them.

Critical reviews only accounted for 2% of total reviews, and the primary complaint seemed to be that these people received toys that were already broken. Others mention the overall quality of the toy set is subpar, but some mention they expected this.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Ailuki Assorted Catnip Toy Set an overall 9/10-star rating. The breakdown of our ratings is below:

  • Pet Suitability (10/10): There is something for every kind of cat in this toy package.  
  • Material Quality (7/10): Most of the toys are of good quality, but some of them feel rather cheap. 
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): Each toy in this set averages just 45 cents.
  • Customer Feedback (10/10): Over 15,000 reviews have been written, with only 2% of them being 1 or 2 stars.  
  • Care and Cleanability (7/10): The feather toys can easily lose their feathers, and this is next to impossible to prevent. The other toys can be washed by hand fairly easily if needed.
  • Product Variety (10/10): Over 30 toys are included in this pack. 

Cat Dancer 101 Dancer Interactive Cat Toy

Cat Dancer 101 Dancer Interactive Cat Toy

Get it on Amazon

Price: $2.65

Toy Type: Interactive teaser toy

Pet: Cats

Lifestage: Cats of all ages

Recommended Uses: Attach to a fixed point and alert your cat to its being there. Entice the to play by batting the cardboard roll and showing them how it works. Supervise them when in use to mitigate the risk of injury.

Material: Metal spring; Cardboard

Summary: Cats love to bat and chase things that move erratically. This tiny roll of cardboard attached to the end of a long spring does just that. It moves in ways that attract cats from a distance and help them hone their hunting and playing skills.

The spring can be attached to a fixed place, so the cardboard roll is free hanging in the air. When hung around the cat’s eye level, the cardboard roll is right at the perfect height to attract them from across the room.

Pros
  • Made in the USA
  • Over 8 million sold
  • Teases cats and improves their paw coordination
  • Simple design that is easy to use
  • Very affordable
Cons
  • The spring can pose a hazard to your cat
  • The cardboard roll can be chewed and swallowed

Customer Reviews: Cat owners loved this toy. They posted numerous pictures and videos of their cats playing with the toy and smiling about it. Their cats dance around as they chase the tiny roll of cardboard, and buyers were happy with the price.

Negative reviews were warning of potential choking hazards from the roll of cardboard and raised concerns over the spring that can swing around wildly and injure someone nearby or their cat.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Cat Dancer 101 Dancer Interactive Cat Toy an overall 8/10-star rating. The breakdown of our ratings is below:

  • Pet Suitability (9/10): The whacky waving action is great at getting most cats’ attention.
  • Material Quality (10/10): The simple design helps to make it easy to produce with high quality.  
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): For under 3 dollars, you can offer your cat hours of playtime.
  • Customer Feedback (10/10): Almost 30,000 reviews have been made on Amazon, and 90% of them are positive.
  • Care and Cleanability (9/10): This was very easy to maintain, with the only relative pain point being the cardboard roll.
  • Product Variety (5/10):  There is only one variety offered for this toy, but it is great at what it is designed to do.

Youngever Kitten Toys Assortments

Youngever Kitten Toys Assortments

Get it on Amazon

Price: $12.50

Toy Type: Wands, Balls, Mice, Tunnels

Pet: Cats

Lifestage: Cats of all ages

Recommended Uses: When your cat is bored, offer them a variety of toys. This can be one toy or multiple. Put away toys your cat does not use, and when their preferred toys are worn out or lost, replace them with new toys. Watch out for loose or broken pieces that could pose a choking hazard.

Material: Plastic; Cotton; Feathers

Summary: Cats have different play styles based on their lifestyle, breed, energy level, etc. This assortment of toys is made to be suited for nearly all styles of play with balls, feathers, and a tunnel. It is all available for less than 50 cents per toy.

The two cat tunnels give cats a space to practice their ambushing skills, and a long teaser wand allows you to play one-on-one with your cat. Feather balls, pom poms, and bells are included to help cats keep up with their pawing and batting skills. It is perfect for houses with multiple cats and for beginner cat owners who do not yet have a stockpile of old cat toys built up.

Pros
  • Assorted toys
  • Provides loads of stimulation variations
  • Great for multi-cat households or beginner cat owners
  • Suitable for cats of all ages
  • Tens of thousands of reviews give us a clear picture of what to expect when buying this product
Cons
  • Includes small parts
  • Does not have catnip toys

Customer Reviews: Over 90% of reviews on Amazon are positive. These people say their indoor cats love this toy set, with the favorite toy being the two-way cat tunnel. The crinkle balls, feather toys, and bells received mixed reviews, but few cat owners had problems with them.

Only 4% of reviews were critical, and these buyers were disappointed with the overall quality of the toys. The feathers came out, and the tunnel had wires that would be revealed soon after they introduced their cats to it.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Youngever Kitten Toys Assortments an overall 9/10-star rating. The breakdown of our ratings is below:

  • Pet Suitability (10/10): There is something in this variety pack for every cat.
  • Material Quality (7/10): Some of the toys are a bit cheap and easy to break.  
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): This is a very affordable and practical cat toy set.
  • Customer Feedback (10/10): Tens of thousands of reviews have been written on this product, and over 90% are 4 and 5-star reviews.  
  • Care and Cleanability (8/10): The plush toys were stitched together well, so they need almost no maintenance but the cat tunnel cat tear.
  • Product Variety (9/10): There is nearly every kind of toy in this toy set, but there are no catnip toys.

SPOT Ethical Interactive Catnip Cat Toy

SPOT Ethical Interactive Catnip Cat Toy

Get it on Amazon

Price: $2.64

Toy Type: Catnip toy

Pet: Cats

Lifestage: Adult cats

Recommended Uses: Give to your cat for playtime after meals or when you are going to be gone for an extended period. Take away from your cat when they have lost interest in it and offer it to them again no sooner than one hour later to avoid potential side effects.

Material: Plastic; Catnip

Summary: As far as catnip-filled toys go, these are about as easy and as simple to use as it gets. The springy rubber plastic sheath houses catnip that is tricky for cats to take out with their claws. This not only helps their scratching but also helps to stimulate their brain as they try to get to the catnip they so desire to reach.

Catnip is not suited for all cats; these catnip tubes are best suited for adult cats who can feel the effects of catnip. The plastic strings that thread together create a tough exterior that is resistant to heavy biting and chewing. A plastic bag inside the tube houses the catnip and keeps it from tearing and clawing through the bag.

Pros
  • Made with catnip
  • Comes in multi-packs
  • No assembly required
  • Easy to carry and toss around
  • Springy action supports agility and bone density maintenance
Cons
  • The catnip fades quickly
  • Easy to lose

Customer Reviews: Cat owners generally loved this catnip-filled toy. Their cats went crazy for them and would carry them around, leaving them wherever they felt it was safe to hide their prized possessions.

Critical pet owners expressed concerns over choking hazards from the small bag of catnip that is inside the tube. Other buyers mentioned the plastic tubes coming apart and said they were worried about it posing a threat to their felines.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving SPOT Ethical Interactive Catnip Cat Toy an overall 7/10-star rating. The breakdown of our ratings is below:

  • Pet Suitability (8/10): For the most part, this is a very cat-friendly toy, but it is possible to get the bag of catnip out.
  • Material Quality (8/10): Overall, this is a high-quality toy, but the plastic strings that thread together and make up the tube can be pulled apart during playtime.  
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): Totaling less than $1.00 per toy, this is a great value for the money.
  • Customer Feedback (7/10): The overall ratings for this cat toy are about average for cat toys on Amazon.
  • Care and Cleanability (9/10): These are very easy to care for and require no cleaning.
  • Product Variety (9/10): There are three size options, and each option comes with at least three catnip tubes.

PETMATE Doskocil Crazies Cat Toy

PETMATE Doskocil Crazies Cat Toy

Get it on Amazon

Price: $4.99

Toy Type: Chaser toy

Pet: Cats

Lifestage: Cats of all ages

Recommended Uses: Offer to your cat to provide relief from boredom. Give these toys to your cat and keep away from fragile or unsecured furniture, as these are made to be thrown around during intense play sessions.

Material: Plastic

Summary: Cats enjoy tossing and chasing their prey, and these chasing toys are created specifically for that purpose. As your cat bats at them, they flip upward and become caught on their paws. The cat flicks its paw to release the toy from its fur and chases it once it has been let loose.

The durable plastic these toys are made of is safe and non-toxic to cats if ingested. Four come in one pack, so you can have a stash saved up for when your cat loses them under the couch or behind the refrigerator. The bright colors are easy to see on the floor to help reduce the chance of stepping on them or losing them.

Pros
  • Fantastic for agility and tossing practice
  • Small and easy for your cat to throw and carry
  • Promotes interaction and fun
  • Brightly colored, so they are easy to see on the floor
  • Small, simple design requires no maintenance
Cons
  • Easily lost due to the nature of play they encourage
  • The plastic can be broken rather easily

Customer Reviews: Thousands of happy cat owners have cats who love these toys. Reviews titles such as “my cats love them” and “cats adore these” are extremely common on Amazon. Not every buyer was happy with these tossing rings, though.

These cat owners were disappointed by their cat’s lack of interest in the toys. Other negative reviews say their cats swallowed the toy whole, and although they were able to pass them fine, their owners were concerned about this behavior.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving PETMATE Doskocil Crazies Cat Toy an overall 8/10-star rating. The breakdown of our ratings is below:

  • Pet Suitability (7/10): These toys are made of safe, non-toxic plastic, but numerous customers complain their cats were not interested in them. 
  • Material Quality (10/10): Few reviews were left stating these had broke at any time, and we did not experience any defects in these toys. In fact, some reviews say their cat swallowed and passed this toy, and it remained entirely intact.
  • Cost Effectiveness (8/10): Priced at just over $1.00 per toy, these are not expensive, but they are not the cheapest toy on this list.
  • Care and Cleanability (8/10): These are easy to lose but are durable and do not require cleaning.
  • Customer Feedback (9/10): Over 4,000 reviews have been left on Amazon, but just over 80% are positive. This is great but not the best ratio of positive to negative reviews we have seen.  
  • Product Variety (9/10): Four toys come in one multi-colored package, but only one option is available to buy.

Ontel Flippity Fish Interactive Cat Toy with Catnip & Fishing Pole

Ontel Flippity Fish Interactive Cat Toy with Catnip & Fishing Pole

Get it on Amazon

Price: $5.79

Toy Type: Electric/rechargeable

Pet: Cats

Lifestage: Cats of all ages

Recommended Uses: Charge fully and turn it on, then give it to your cat. It is touch activated, so you may need to show them how to use it at first by touching and getting the unit to move and intrigue your cat.

Material: Cotton; Plastic; Rubber

Summary: This automated toy flips and flops around as your cat paws at it. The motion sensors inside of it detect the impact of its paws and cause it to react by jumping around like a fish out of water. This mimics how a fish would react in real life and stimulates your cat’s hunting instincts.

Made of durable, non-toxic materials, this fish toy is also able to hold catnip to further encourage your cat to play with it. As a bonus, a fishing pole is included in the package, and this creates an interactive play experience and a great bonding opportunity between cat and human. It is safe for solo play, so you can leave it out while you aren’t home to give your cat a source of entertainment while you’re away.

Pros
  • USB rechargeable
  • Flips and flops as your cat bats at it
  • Mimics real fish on land
  • Non-toxic and machine washable
  • Can be filled with catnip
Cons
  • The plastic hook on the fishing pole can pose a choking hazard
  • Does not come with catnip

Customer Reviews: People’s cats seemed to love this toy “at all hours of the day or night,” as the top review put it. For them, their cats were very happy with the action of the toy, and some people said even their dogs enjoyed it.

Other buyers brought up concerns about the hook posing a choking hazard and said it made so much noise as it bounced around their cats were afraid of it. The most common complaint, however, was that the battery would not hold a charge.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Ontel Flippity Fish Interactive Cat Toy with Catnip & Fishing Pole an overall 8/10-star rating. The breakdown of our ratings is below:

  • Pet Suitability (10/10): This toy mimics real-life fish and is safe for solo play.
  • Material Quality (6/10): The battery does not hold a charge for very long, and the plastic hook on the fishing pole feels cheap and brittle.
  • Cost Effectiveness (8/10): The price itself is 10/10, but the quality is a bit low in some areas and is likely to malfunction, causing you to have to buy another one or a better one. For this reason, it can end up costing more than the initial $6.00 price tag.
  • Care and Cleanability (5/10): This was a high-maintenance toy that required charging and cleaning to operate safely.
  • Customer Feedback (7/10): There are over 12,000 reviews, which is great, but less than 70% of those reviews were positive and highly rated. 
  • Product Variety (9/10): There is only one version of this toy available.

What Should I Look for in Cheap Cat Toys?

Here are some things to consider when buying cheap cat toys:

  • Assortment: Many cheap and inexpensive cat toys come in a variety of packs. The best cat toy packages come with cat tunnels, puzzle toys, and dispensers for cat treats, but not all variety packs are made the same. Be on the lookout for specific toys your cat likes in a given assortment.
  • Enrichment Type: Pet products are generally made to enrich a pet’s life. Pet supplies like cat trees and cat scratchers enrich your cat’s life by giving them a place of their own, and cat toys give them enrichment via mental and physical stimulation.
  • Quality: Quality and cheap don’t often go together, but that doesn’t mean you can’t find suitable inexpensive cat toys. Be on the lookout for things that can easily be chewed off, like the eyes on a mouse or the feather of a cat wand toy, as these are more likely to come off on less expensive cat toys.