The Best Christmas Cat Toys: Our Top Picks Reviewed
Table of Contents
We include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission.
What Should I Give My Cat for Christmas?
- Best Overall Christmas Cat Toys: Sanlebi Assorted Christmas Cat Toys Stocking
With 10 pieces of fun assorted toys, these make for the best Christmas cat toys you can get. - Best Value Christmas Cat Toys: Whaline Christmas Cat Toys
This cat toys Christmas package contains as many as 17 different toys at an affordable rate. - Best Christmas Cat Toys Packaging: Lepawit Cat Christmas Toys with Cat Wand Toy, Catnip Toys, Crinkle Balls, and Mice
For cat owners that are looking for nicely packaged Christmas gifts, this is one of the best. - Best Outfit Christmas Cat Toys: senyouth Cat Christmas Costume and Toys
Cat lovers will enjoy the outfit coming with this Christmas gift, and will make cats look cute. - Best Christmas Cat Toy For Chasing: ATICNECH Interactive Christmas Cat Chase Ball Toys with Bell
The shape and design of these Christmas balls make them ideal for cats that enjoy chasing. - Best Christmas Cat Toy For New Cats: SmartyKat Merry Medley Christmas Cat Toy
The basic and fun design of this variety pack is ideal for new pet parents to spoil their cats. - Most Sparkly Christmas Cat Toy: FLYSTAR Christmas Stocking and Interactive Cat Toys
For curious cats that enjoy a sparkly toy set, this holiday cat toy makes for a perfect gift idea. - Best Christmas Cat Toy For Feather-Loving Cats: APSUAE Replaceable and Retractable Christmas Cat Toy
This cat toy gift is ideal for cats that enjoy tinkering around with feather types of cat toys.
- 10 PCS cat toys including colorful wrinkle balls, mouse, Santa Claus, elk, candy, fur balls, etc. All toys are stored in Christmas stockings.
- The interactive cat toys are made of high-quality materials, very durable and safe for your pet cat.
- Variety of cat toys with sounds and different shapes can meet all the needs of cats and provide hours of entertainment for your cat.
Why Should I Buy My Cat Christmas Toys?
Christmas cat toys bring all the benefits of cat toys with the added holiday note. Here are some of the reasons to buy Christmas cat toys and kitten toys:
- Safe Playing: When your cat gets some stocking stuffers from Santa, it encourages them to play with safe pet toys that are designed for exactly that. This will deter them from playing with other Christmas decorations that might pose health risks.
- Mental Stimulation: Getting a ball cat toy, wand cat toy, cat teaser, or spring cat toy will keep your cat mentally stimulated while you’re Christmas shopping for other holiday gifts.
- Reduce Stress: Getting some new cat toys to leave under the Christmas tree will help alleviate the anxiety and stress your cat might experience.
- Overall Health: Cats that play with toys during the holiday season will burn more calories and be healthier than cats that remain stagnant on the cat bed all day.
The Best Christmas Cat Toys Reviewed
There are a variety of great Christmas cat toys on the market. With so many fun options, it can be hard for pet owners to find the best cat toy for their furry friends. Therefore, we have selected and reviewed some of the best Christmas cat toys on Amazon and Chewy.
Price: $9.99
Toy Type: Assorted plush toys
Pet: Cat
Lifestage: Cats of all ages
Recommended Uses: These Christmas cat toys are recommended for cats that enjoy playing with soft, plush objects in a safe and fun way.
Material: Cotton
Summary: This 10-piece gift set of cat toys will appeal to all types of cats. It includes wrinkle balls and other Christmas-themed toys that are constructed with safe, high-quality material. This variety pack of uniquely-shaped Christmas toys will lead to hours of enjoyment for your cat.
If you’re looking for a safe and fun way to enjoy the holiday season with your cat, this product will go a long way in encouraging that.
- 10 toys
- Christmas-themed
- Safe for all ages
- Durable built
- Indoor and outdoor use
- Doesn’t include a Santa toy
- Some of the toys are a little small
Customer Reviews: These Christmas cat toys are rated 4.7 out of 5 stars on Amazon. Customers rate it highly for the wide variety of toys that appeal to many different types of cats.
Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Sanlebi Assorted Christmas Cat Toys Stocking an overall 10/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:
- Pet Suitability (10/10): We rate this so highly because it appeals to so many types of cats. It’s perfect for both indoor and outdoor use and is very durable.
- Material Quality (10/10): The cotton material in this product is soft and safe for long play sessions.
- Cost Effectiveness (10/10): With a price of only $9.99, most cat owners will find this 10-piece package a great addition to their cat’s toy collection.
- Customer Feedback (10/10): Customer feedback for this toy is exceptionally high and only a fraction under a perfect 5/5 stars on Amazon. Customers mention that the images of this product online look exactly how they are in person and that their cats loved it.
- Product Variety (10/10): This product contains a total of 10 Christmas cat toys of varying shapes, sizes, and sounds.
Price: $12.99
Toy Type: Variety package
Pet: Cat
Lifestage: Cats of all ages
Recommended Uses: These Christmas cat toys are recommended for indoor use.
Material: Non-woven fabric, Artificial feather material, Plush/cotton balls, Rattan, Plastic
Summary: This value pack includes 17 different cat toys that will appeal to many different types of cats. The material used to manufacture these toys are all safe, durable, and comfortable for cats’ mouths.
Included with the product is a Christmas stocking crafted from non-woven material. With such a large number of products included in this package, cats will remain mentally stimulated for hours.
- 17 cat toys
- Safe material
- Stocking included
- Good for curious cats
- Interactive design
- Some of the smaller toys might go missing
- 17 toys being left around the house might create clutter
Customer Reviews: These Christmas cat toys are rated 4.6 out of 5 stars across 189 reviews on Amazon. It’s highly rated for having so many cute Christmas toys that appeal to kittens, all the way to senior cats.
Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Whaline Christmas Cat Toys an overall 10/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:
- Pet Suitability (10/10): This 17-piece Christmas cat toy package is suitable for all types of indoor cats that need to be mentally stimulated.
- Material Quality (10/10): The safe material used in these toys include non-woven fabric, a cat stick, plush, paper, and cotton balls, making them ideal for all types of cats.
- Cost Effectiveness (10/10): It’s difficult to rate this any lower than 10/10 due to how many fun and interactive toys you’re getting in this package. Each toy is uniquely-shaped and will bring hours of fun to your cat.
- Customer Feedback (10/10): The majority of customers rate this product very highly. Customers report that these have a great Christmas theme that gets everyone in the festive spirit.
- Product Variety (10/10): Curious cats will love the wide variety of toys included in this package, and each one looks and feels a little bit different from the next.
Price: $14.99
Toy Type: Variety package (catnip toys, cat wand toys, ball)
Pet: Cat
Lifestage: Cats of all ages
Recommended Uses: These Christmas cat toys are recommended for cats that love the sounds toys make when they are swatting or pouncing them.
Material: Artificial feather, Cotton
Summary: This variety pack includes catnip toys, a cat wand toy, balls, and even a toy that looks like a jingle bell. Cats will love the interactive nature of these toys.
When cats jump on them or play with them, they make different sounds. Cats will also enjoy the wide range of shapes and sizes of toys included in this package. A Santa is located on the feather toy, and curious cats will love to swat at the Santa hat.
- 10 different toys
- Catnip toy included
- Safe materials
- Interactive and engaging
- High-quality materials
- Durability
- Some toys are quite small
Customer Reviews: Customers rate these Christmas cat toys 4.5 out of 5 stars on Amazon. Cat owners said that their cats especially loved the balls and catnip toys in the package.
Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Lepawit Cat Christmas Toys with Cat Wand Toy, Catnip Toys, Crinkle Balls, and Mice an overall 10/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:
- Pet Suitability (10/10): This Christmas cat toy is ideal for cats that love a good measure of interactivity in their toys.
- Material Quality (10/10): With the high-quality and safe materials used to manufacture this product, cat owners will never have to worry about their cats becoming injured after long-term use of these toys. The fabric is non-toxic and soft on the mouth.
- Cost Effectiveness (10/10): This toy is affordably-priced at $14.99, and with 10 different toys included, you’re getting a good deal.
- Customer Feedback (9/10): While the positive feedback from the majority of customers is astounding, one did mention that they received the product with broken toys due to the packaging.
- Product Variety (10/10): In this package, you’ll get a cat wand, 4 ball toys, 2 crinkle balls, and 3 catnip toys.
Price: $8.99
Toy Type: Variety pack (plush toys, costumes, balls)
Pet: Cat
Lifestage: Cats of all ages
Recommended Uses: These Christmas cat toys are recommended for smaller types of cats that don’t mind costumes.
Material: Plastic, Cotton
Summary: For pet cats that don’t mind dressing up for Christmas, there are a total of 9 cat toys and a costume included in this package.
There are also crinkle balls, a bell, a catnip toy, and a sparkle toy that cats will find exhilarating and entertaining. Natural materials were used to manufacture the cat toys in this package, making them tasteless and non-toxic.
- Comes with a cat costume
- 9 toys in one pack
- Interactive cat toys
- High-quality materials
- Easy to use
- The costume might not fit all cats
- Some cats may get bored with certain toys
Customer Reviews: These Christmas cat toys are rated 4.5 out of 5 stars on Amazon. It’s highly rated by cat owners that enjoy dressing their cats up in outfits while they enjoy playtime.
Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving senyouth Cat Christmas Costume and Toys an overall 9/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:
- Pet Suitability (9/10): This product is perfect for cats that don’t mind getting dressed up for the occasion. The only reason we don’t give it a solid 10/10 for pet suitability is that not all cats will feel comfortable in costumes.
- Material Quality (10/10): With high-quality plastic and soft cotton materials, cats won’t get injured in any way from this product.
- Cost Effectiveness (10/10): This cute Christmas cat toy is only $8.99, and that makes it perfect for anyone on a budget over the Christmas season.
- Customer Feedback (9/10): Customers love how cute their cats look wearing the Santa cape, but one customer did mention that their cat didn’t care for it.
- Product Variety (10/10): The product variety included in this package is great. You get a costume, a sparkle bell, and a number of crinkle balls included.
Price: $9.99
Toy Type: Ball toy
Pet: Cat, rabbits, puppies
Lifestage: Cats of all ages
Recommended Uses: These Christmas cat toys are recommended for pets that love chasing around objects. It can also be used for decoration.
Material: Environmentally-friendly materials
Summary: This Christmas-themed cat kicker toy contains a total of four different ball-shaped toys. The nice thing about this product is that it’s not only limited to cats. If you have a puppy or rabbit, they can only interact with it.
Pets will love interacting with this toy because of the sound it makes when rolling along the ground. The sound will instantly cause the natural instinct of cats to react to it. You can also use these toys as regular Christmas decorations around the home. They are safe and environmentally friendly.
- They can be used as decorations
- Environmentally friendly
- Not only limited to cats
- Safe for cats of all ages
- Great for cats who love to chase things
- Other pets may not find it as fun as cats will
- Bigger dogs might tear it apart
Customer Reviews: These Christmas cat toys are rated 4.4 out of 5 stars on Amazon. Customers rate it highly for its ability to provide cats with hours of chasing-around entertainment.
Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving ATICNECH Interactive Christmas Cat Chase Ball Toys with Bell an overall 10/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:
- Pet Suitability (10/10): For cats who love to chase ball-like objects around the home, this is a perfect Christmas toy to purchase. It’s an interactive cat toy that also makes a funny sound when it rolls around on the ground, and this can spark a cat’s curiosity.
- Material Quality (10/10): Environmentally-friendly materials were used to design this product, and no harm will be done to your cat while it plays with it.
- Cost Effectiveness (10/10): The affordable price of $9.99 makes this toy a must-have for cat owners. Even if your cat doesn’t end up playing with it, the toys can double as Christmas decorations.
- Customer Feedback (10/10): There is nearly no negative feedback for this product. Cat owners suggest this product is ideal for curious cats who love to chase things around the home.
- Product Variety (10/10): The total of 4 different chase balls included in this product gives it 10/10 for product variety.
Price: $43.26
Toy Type: Plush
Pet: Cat
Lifestage: Cats of all ages
Recommended Uses: These Christmas cat toys are recommended for cats that enjoy multi-textured objects.
Material: Artificial feathers, Ribbons, Plastic, Catnip
Summary: This package includes plush cat toys that have a variety of different textures. The toys are stimulating and perfect for cats that like interacting with objects.
Safety is a priority for SmartKat, so you’ll never have to worry about your cat or children getting injured by this toy. The company is all about designing products that fulfill the needs of them and their cats.
- Safe for cats & kids
- Multi-textured variety
- Lightweight design
- Stimulating nature
- 16 toys for added fun
- Some of the toys feel flimsy
- Price
Customer Reviews: These Christmas cat toys are rated 4.7 out of 5 stars across 474 reviews on Amazon. Customers report that their cats thoroughly enjoyed this product, and the majority of reviewers report that it’s their cat’s new favorite toy.
Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving SmartyKat Merry Medley Christmas Cat Toy an overall 9/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:
- Pet Suitability (10/10): This Christmas cat toy is perfect for all types of cats. The stimulating catnip toys will encourage cats to interact with these toys for hours on end.
- Material Quality (10/10): The feathers, plastic, plush, plastic, and ribbons in this cat toy mimic the feel of real prey for cats.
- Cost Effectiveness (8/10): Some customers will find this product to be higher priced than some of the other ones on the market.
- Customer Feedback (9/10): Most customers love this product and mentioned that they’ll be ordering more in the future. One customer mentioned they only received 10 toys out of the total 16-toy package, but that’s not the norm.
- Product Variety (10/10): In this product, you have the option of purchasing a set of 9, 13, 16, or 18.
Price: $16.99
Toy Type: Ball toys
Pet: Cats
Lifestage: Cats of all ages
Recommended Uses: These Christmas cat toys are recommended for medium to large-sized cats that tend to get bored easily.
Material: Artificial feather, Non-toxic materials, Fabric
Summary: For cats that tend to get bored easily and take their frustration out on furniture or other objects around the home, this product will fulfill that stress. There are a total of 13 cat toys included in this package for cats to pounce on.
For customers looking for a gift box that’s shaped like a stocking, this can be a perfect Christmas package for you or a friend.
- Designed for safety
Helps with cat boredom
Excellent cost-to-value ratio
13 pieces
Ideal for all types of cats
- Some customers might find the products lack originality
- Geared toward medium to larger cats
Customer Reviews: These Christmas cat toys are rated 4.3 out of 5 stars on Amazon. It’s rated positively for keeping cats mentally stimulated for long periods of time in a safe and effective way.
Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving FLYSTAR Christmas Stocking and Interactive Cat Toys an overall 10/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:
- Pet Suitability (10/10): This Christmas cat toy is perfect for cats who tend to get bored easily. With a total of 13 different pieces in this package, cats will feel less bored in the home.
- Material Quality (10/10): We like how the manufacturer used non-toxic materials in all of the toys included in this package. That makes them safe and healthy for all cats to use.
- Cost Effectiveness (10/10): While the price tag of $16.99 isn’t the cheapest price point on this list, it’s still very affordable for what you’re getting included in it.
- Customer Feedback (10/10): The only negative review on this cat toy was that the customer accidentally took the toy out of the package too soon, resulting in their cat wanting to instantly play with it before Christmas.
- Product Variety (10/10): We like that the manufacturer included a number of sparkly cat toys in this package. This will appeal to curious cats that like a bit of shine in the objects they interact with.
Price: $12.99
Toy Type: Plush wand toy
Pet: Cat
Lifestage: Cats of all ages
Recommended Uses: These Christmas cat toys are recommended for indoor cats that enjoy swatting and playing around with wand toys.
Material: Catnip, Nylon rope, Artificial feathers, Plastic
Summary: For cats that enjoy swatting at things, this is a must-have Christmas gift. It’s also perfect for owners that enjoy interacting with their cats because they have to hold the wands.
Everything included in this package is carefully designed with safe materials that will last a long time. The plush toys include catnip, and this is an effective way of relieving stress and anxiety. Wands range from 15 to 38 inches in size.
- Great for cats that enjoy wand toys
- Encourages bonding
- High-quality material
- Catnip included in the plush toys
- 9-piece package
- Durability
- Some customers report it breaking after a while
Customer Reviews: These Christmas cat toys received 4.5 out of 5 stars across 117 reviews on Amazon. Customers love how it has so many attachments, and they point out that their cats enjoy interacting with it for hours.
Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving APSUAE Replaceable and Retractable Christmas Cat Toy an overall 9/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:
- Pet Suitability (10/10): For cat owners that like spending time playing with their cats, using wands is often a great way to encourage that. With a set of retractable wands, feathers, and even a Christmas tree, this package promotes safe and interactive play.
- Material Quality (8/10): Artificial feathers, nylon rope, and plastic are some of the materials in this product. Some customers mention they feel a little flimsy, which leads us to reduce a point or two for material quality.
- Cost Effectiveness (10/10): If you’re looking for an affordably-priced best seller that encourages interactive play, the $12.99 price tag is worth it.
- Customer Feedback (8/10): While the toy may not have gingerbread men included in it, customers do love how much more active their cats are after purchasing this product. There are a few customers that mention the toys didn’t last very long.
- Product Variety (9/10): We like that this Christmas cat toy included a wand and a variety of feathers. Curious cats will find it stimulating.
What Should I Look for in a Christmas Cat Toy?
There are a couple of things to look for in Christmas cat toys:
- Safety: Safety should be the number one concern when looking for Christmas cat toys. Products should be manufactured with non-toxic materials without sharp objects that might pose a risk to your cat’s health.
- Durability: Christmas cat toys should be durable and long-lasting. Keep an eye out for products that are highly rated for their materials.
- Stimulation: Christmas cat toys need to be stimulating. Focus on ball toys, wands, and toys that contain catnip to reduce your cat’s anxiety levels.
- Christmas Theme: Christmas cat toys should have a Christmas theme behind them. You might find toys in the shape of Santa, Christmas trees, elves, and other holiday designs.
- Toy Weight: Is the toy too heavy for your cat to pick up? If so, it won’t last long and will probably end up being pushed under the couch instead of being played with.
How do I Spoil My Cat for Christmas?
Christmas cat toys are a great way of spoiling your cat during the holiday season. However, they are not the only ones. Here are some other ideas for spoiling your feline friend:
- Comfort: Cats love comfortable spaces to relax in. Consider getting a nice cat bed for your cat to relax in after it plays with its Christmas gifts.
- Brushing: Give your cat some pampering by brushing it every now and then. Cats love being scratched around their ear areas.
- Scratch Post: A new scratch post is always a good idea. This will give them something to do in the event that their old scratcher has been destroyed by your dog or the vacuum cleaner.
- Catnip Toys: These make for a great gift for any age feline. You can find these at most pet stores, and they come in wide varieties, including stuffed animals and balls with catnip inside. Ideally, you should look for toys with organic catnip.
- Heater: If you have an outdoor cat, now might be the time to get it an outdoor heater so it can enjoy cuddling under a nice warm blanket during those cold winter months.
