What Are the Best Halloween Cat Toys?

  • Best Overall Halloween Cat Toys: CiyvoLyeen Halloween Catnip Toys
    With a total of six different designs that can be used either indoors or outdoors, this is the best overall Halloween cat toy product on the market.
  • Best Costume Halloween Cat Toys: Coppthinktu Halloween Pet Bat Wings
    The felt cloth material on this Halloween costume is ideal for black cats that don’t mind dressing for the occasion.
  • Best USA-Made Halloween Cat Toys: Yeowww Catnip Pumpkins
    Shaped like a jack-o-lantern, this fun Halloween pumpkin toy is stuffed with organic catnip and made in the USA.
CiyvoLyeen Halloween Catnip Toys
  • The package comes with 6 different designs pumpkin, black cat, ghost, bat, spider, and skull. With the good-smelling catnip in it, they can help relieve the fatigue of the kitten and help the cat to keep healthy.
  • Each cat toy is stuffed with organic catnip with polyester fiber fill. They’re soft and durable for indoor or outdoor cats chewing and teething.
  • The catnip toys can stimulate more exercise in cats and strengthen the interaction between you and cats. 

The Best Halloween Cat Toys Reviewed

Halloween cat toys are fun and add extra holiday spirit to your cat’s playing sessions. To help you find the best Halloween-themed pet toy for your cat, we have reviewed our top picks.

CiyvoLyeen Halloween Catnip Toys

CiyvoLyeen Halloween Catnip Toys

Get it on Amazon

Price: $17.99

Toy Type: Catnip chew toy

Pet: Cat

Lifestage: Ideal for cats of all life stages.

Recommended Uses: This plush cat toy package is recommended for both indoor cats and outdoor cats that like to pounce on floppy objects.

Material: Organic catnip, Polyester fiber

Summary: Many customers click checkout on this product because it comes in a package of 6 uniquely designed Halloween cat toys that are all stuffed with catnip. High-quality plush material is used to fill these cat toys. These Halloween cat toys are perfect for cats that enjoy chewing on objects.

It’s also ideal for cats that are teething or just require some additional mental stimulation. Cats that enjoy scratcher toys will also find this product to be fun to play around with. It can increase exercise levels and also clean the teeth.

Pros
  • Encourages dental hygiene
  • Interactive
  • Makes for a good Halloween gift
  • Good for kittens who are teething
Cons
  • Could use some variety in design
  • A wand extension would be nice

Customer Reviews: Customers rate this product 4.8 out of 5 stars on Amazon. Customers enjoy how much fun this product is and that once their cats begin playing with it, they become obsessed with it.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving CiyvoLyeen Halloween Catnip Toys an overall 10/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:

  • Pet Suitability (10/10): We rate this so high for pet suitability because young and older cats will both find it to be entertaining and interactive to play with.
  • Material Quality (10/10): High-quality organic catnip is used in this product.
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): With what you get included in this package for $17.99, the price is affordable for most cat owners with the quality that you’re also getting.
  • Customer Feedback (10/10): There are next to no negative reviews surrounding this trending product, and many customers get it while quantities last.
  • Product Variety (10/10): With a total of 6 different cat toys ranging from a pumpkin, black cat, ghost, bat, spider, and skull, we give the product variety 10/10.

Kingyao Halloween Mochi Squishy Toys

Kingyao Halloween Mochi Squishy Toys

Get it on Amazon

Price: $9.99

Toy Type: Squishy ball cat toy

Pet: Cat

Lifestage: Ideal for cats at all life stages.

Recommended Uses: This product is recommended for cat owners that need a variety of different squishy toys to keep their cats stimulated.

Material: Thermoplastic rubber

Summary: The nice thing about this cat toy is that it doubles as a toy that’s perfect for including in Halloween gift bags. Some of the mini toys in this package are a witch hat, pumpkin cat toy, Halloween candy, and many other Halloween cat toys and kitten toys that will keep them occupied.

With 24 different Halloween cat toys included in this package, cats will stay stimulated for hours. These toys can also act as Halloween decorations around the home. The soft material feels good on hands and cat mouths.

Pros
  • 24 different toys
  • You can use them as decorations
  • Kids enjoy them
  • Easy to clean
  • You can squeeze, stretch, and twist them
Cons
  • No catnip
  • Durability

Customer Reviews: This product is rated 4.6 out of 5 stars on Amazon. Customers highly rate it for its soft feel, affordability, and how its giftable.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Kingyao Halloween Mochi Squishy Toys an overall 9/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:

  • Pet Suitability (9/10): This pack of 24 toys is ideal for younger to older cats. With so much variety included, you can’t go wrong.
  • Material Quality (9/10): The rubber used is safe for cats.  
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): At $9.99 for 24 toys, you’re getting a lot for what you’re paying.
  • Customer Feedback (10/10): The majority of customers love how these toys are perfect for cats, and children, and as decorations.
  • Product Variety (10/10): The 24 Halloween toy options ranging from pumpkin to eyeballs, give the product an excellent variety.

Lepawit Cat Wand Toys with Feather and Catnip

Lepawit Cat Wand Toys with Feather and Catnip

Get it on Amazon

Price: $12.99

Toy Type: Teaser wand

Pet: Cats

Lifestage: This product is suitable for cats of all ages and life stages

Recommended Uses: These interactive wands are recommended for indoor cats that have an interest in hunting.

Material: Natural feather, Natural catnip, Felt fabric

Summary: There are a total of 4 different cat wands included in this product. Each of them contains natural feathers and catnip. Cats with a natural hunting instinct will find these toys to be irresistible.

Perfect for curing boredom and helping with anxiety, the safe material in these toys will keep cats occupied for hours. Cat owners that want to bond with their cats through interaction will also find these Halloween cat toys fun to use.

Pros
  • Interactive
  • 4 different wands
  • Safe materials
  • Good customer service
  • Interesting embroidery
Cons
  • Durability
  • Some cats may not enjoy it

Customer Reviews: This product is rated 4.6 out of 5 stars on Amazon. Customers mention how their cats crave this toy nonstop. They mention the product is designed with quality in mind and that it’s fun to play with.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Lepawit Cat Wand Toys with Feather and Catnip an overall 10/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:

  • Pet Suitability (10/10): For cats with a strong hunting instinct, these wands will keep them occupied for hours.
  • Material Quality (10/10): The wands come with premium catnip.
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): These affordably priced wands are of great value for how much fun and entertainment cats will get out of them.
  • Customer Feedback (9/10): Most customers mention how their cats couldn’t get enough of these wands and that they always came back for more.
  • Product Variety (10/10): With a pack of four different wands in, we give the product variety 10/10.

Coppthinktu Halloween Pet Bat Wings

Coppthinktu Halloween Pet Bat Wings

Get it on Amazon

Price: $3.59

Toy Type: Costume

Pet: Cats and dogs

Lifestage: This is suitable for cats and smaller dogs of all life stages.

Recommended Uses: This product is recommended for cats and dogs that don’t mind dressing up for Halloween.

Material: Black felt cloth

Summary: This felt cloth costume will give your cat or dog black bat wings. The easy-to-use product will have your cat or dog look more stylish and unique. It will get everyone in your family into the Halloween spirit, and you may even get a few scares out of guests. The velcro design makes size adjustment straightforward.

The costume also doubles as a dog toy. However, dog owners that purchase this product should keep in mind the size dimensions. While the size is adjustable, it may not work for larger dogs.

Pros
  • Works for both cats and dogs
  • Easy to adjust
  • Create a festive atmosphere
  • Bat design
  • Soft material
Cons
  • Sizing may not be the most accurate
  • Feels a little cheap

Customer Reviews: This product is rated 4.4 out of 5 stars on Amazon Customers mention how much they enjoyed its lightweight design, how affordable it is, and how cute it looks.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Coppthinktu Halloween Pet Bat Wings an overall 9/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:

  • Pet Suitability (10/10): This customer is suitable for both cats and smaller breeds of dogs. Ensure to look at the sizing when purchasing it.
  • Material Quality (10/10): The felt cloth is comfy for pets to wear.
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): Priced at only $3.59, you’re getting a fun and enjoyable product for what you’re paying.
  • Customer Feedback (9/10): Nearly all of the customers that purchased this product find it to be a cute and adorable costume that looks great on their cats. Customers mention it’s good quality for the money.
  • Product Variety (7/10): One variation of this product is available, however, the design is fit for both cats and dogs.

Yeowww Catnip Pumpkins

Yeowww Catnip Pumpkins

Get it on Amazon

Price: $9.49

Toy Type: Catnip toy

Pet: Cat

Lifestage: Ideal for all types of cats at all life stages.

Recommended Uses: This product is recommended for anxious cats that need something to take their anxiety and boredom out on.

Material: Catnip

Summary: This is a cat scratch catnip pumpkin cat toy that is made in the USA. The toy is only 3”, making it perfect for all sizes of cats. The organically grown catnip will surely satisfy the stress your cat is facing.

This toy also has a round shape to it. That means it will roll around the floor a bit while your cat is playing with it. Some cats have strong instincts to chase things, and the circular design of this toy will encourage that.

Pros
  • Organically grown catnip
  • Supports chasing instincts
  • Very durable built
  • Highly rated cat toy
  • Made in the USA
Cons
  • Some cats may lose interest in it
  • Only one in the package

Customer Reviews: This product is rated 4.8 out of 5 stars on Amazon. It’s highly rated for its quality and ability to stand out from a lot of other catnip toys on the market.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Yeowww Catnip Pumpkins an overall 9/10-star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:

  • Pet Suitability (10/10): This toy is suitable for cats that love to play with soft catnip toys. Its sturdiness and durability will have cats occupied for long periods of time.
  • Material Quality (10/10): Organically grown catnip.
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): This fun product only costs $9.49, and for the amount of interaction and entertainment your cat will get for that price, it’s hard to beat.
  • Customer Feedback (10/10): This product comes very close to getting 10/10 stars for customer feedback. Customers mention how their cat loves this toy and how they stay occupied by pulling and gnawing at them.
  • Product Variety (5/10): Only one variety.

Lepawit Halloween Catnip Lollipop Toys with Plush Pumpkin Decoration

Lepawit Halloween Catnip Lollipop Toys with Plush Pumpkin Decoration

Get it on Amazon

Price: $17.99

Toy Type: Plush stick toy

Pet: Cat

Lifestage: Ideal for cats of all life stages.

Recommended Uses: This product is recommended for bored cats that like to swipe at objects. It’s also good for cats that need teeth cleaning.

Material: 100% natural matatabi silvervine sticks, Catnip, Felt fabric

Summary: This cat toy makes for the perfect Halloween gift for those that have cats. It comes in a package of five stick pieces and one plush pumpkin you can add catnip lollipops. Your cat’s boredom will be relieved by this interactive toy, and it also gives you a chance to hold the toy while your cat interacts with it.

All natural materials were used to manufacture these Halloween cat toys. The sticks are 100% natural silvervine, the fabric is felt and doesn’t contain any toxins or additives. The company stands behind its products and assured you of quality service every step of the way.

Pros
  • All natural materials
  • Set of 5 pieces and a bonus pumpkin
  • Non-toxic
  • No additives
  • Good for teething cats
Cons
  • Some cats may not play with them
  • Dogs may chew it apart if they get a hold of it

Customer Reviews: This product is rated 4.3 out of 5 stars on Amazon. Customers highly rate it for its durability, cost, and that even their dog wants to play with the toys.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Lepawit Halloween Catnip Lollipop Toys with Plush Pumpkin Decoration an overall 9/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:

  • Pet Suitability (10/10): These are perfectly suited to many cats, and customers repeatedly mention how their cats love playing with them. 
  • Material Quality (10/10): Catnip is included in this product to relieve the boredom of cats.
  • Cost Effectiveness (9/10): This product is priced well for its well-made design and all-natural materials.
  • Customer Feedback (9/10): The majority of customer reviews are positive, and there are only a select few that reported their cats are not interested in it.
  • Product Variety (10/10): There is a lot of product variety included in this package. You get five sticks and a pumpkin where the lollipop sticks can be inserted.

AXEL PETS Halloween Furry Mice Cat Toys with Catnip and Rattle Sound

AXEL PETS Halloween Furry Mice Cat Toys with Catnip and Rattle Sound

Get it on Amazon

Price: $14.95

Toy Type: Teaser wand

Pet: Cat

Lifestage: Ideal for all indoor cats of all life stages.

Recommended Uses: This product is recommended for indoor use for cats that have strong hunting instincts.

Material: Real rabbit fur

Summary: Curious cats with a strong hunting instinct will love the 20 different mice included in this package. While playing with these toys, they will get their physical exercise in due to the energizing catnip scent in each toy. This product is also perfect for cats who enjoy catching things, or just for playing on their own.

The mice in this toy package are 4” in length and come in a variety of colors. They are handmade from real reclaimed rabbit fur. Each toy also makes a rattling sound when your cat plays with it in your haunted house during Halloween. If you have a gift card and a cat, consider purchasing this fun and interactive toy.

Pros
  • Comes in a pack of 20
  • Real rabbit fur
  • Energizing catnip scent
  • Rattle sound
  • Interactive type of toy
Cons
  • Some customers may question the design
  • Certain cats may not be interested

Customer Reviews: These Halloween cat toys are rated 4.5 out of 5 stars on Amazon. It’s highly rated for its affordability, durability, and ability to appeal to make cats that may not otherwise play with synthetic mice toys.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving AXEL PETS Halloween Furry Mice Cat Toys with Catnip and Rattle Sound an overall 9/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below:

  • Pet Suitability (9/10): Due to the real rabbit fur used to manufacture these toys, they are perfect for cats that tend to lose interest in artificial toys.
  • Material Quality (10/10): Catnip is included to entice cats.
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): With each toy mouse designed with real rabbit fur, you’re getting a great deal, especially since it comes in a pack of 20.
  • Customer Feedback (9/10): The majority of customers highly rate this product. There is only a small portion of negative reviews that mention concerns about rabbit fur.
  • Product Variety (10/10): There are a total of 20 toy mice included in this package. 

What Should I Look for in a Halloween Cat Toy?

When shopping for Halloween cat toys, cat lovers need to consider the following features:

  • Safety: Safety is the number one concern to keep in mind when purchasing cat toys. Ensure your cat’s toys won’t have any loose clamps or wires that can accidentally latch onto your cat’s mouth. Also, make sure the cat toys don’t use safety pin attachments anywhere.
  • Theme: When purchasing Halloween cat toys, think of spooky themes. That means you’ll want to get a toy that looks like pumpkins, black-pack cats, witches, candy corn objects, bats, etc.
  • Catnip: Focus on Halloween cat toys that have catnip. Some of the products don’t contain it, and cats are generally more interested in the ones that do.
  • Durability: Cats have sharp claws, and because of that, you should get Halloween cat toys that are sturdy and resistant to falling apart.
  • Cost: If you’re on a budget, get a cheap cat toy that doesn’t end up stretching it too far. There are many products on this list that are affordably priced.