What are the Best Pumpkin Dog Treats?

The Honest Kitchen Pumpkin and Cinnamon Goat’s Milk N’ Cookies
  • Use code VETERINARIANS30 for 30% off
  • PROBIOTIC DOG TREATS: Our Goat's Milk N' Cookies contain real goat's milk which is full of probiotics to support a happy belly.
  • HAPPY & HEALTHY: Flavor meets function in every delicious bite of these healthy, whole grain dog treats.
  • IRRESISTIBLY TASTY: These crunchy cookies are slow baked in small batches to provide your pup with a delicious dip of rich goat's milk, pureed pumpkin, and a touch of sweet cinnamon.

What is a Pumpkin Dog Treat?

Pumpkin dog treats are dog treats made with pumpkin as one of the main ingredients.

Pumpkin is great for dogs with an upset stomach or digestive problems as it contains potassium, fiber, and calcium, and is loaded with health-boosting vitamins.

Are Pumpkin Treats Good For Dogs?

Yes, pumpkin treats are good for dogs. We list some of the primary benefits below:

  • Dietary Supplement. Pumpkin contains a wealth of nutrients. It has fiber for digestive support, vitamins A, E, and C for eye, skin, and immune system health, and minerals like calcium to support strong bones and teeth.
  • Urinary Health. Pumpkin seeds contain antioxidants that are particularly rich in omega-3 fatty acids. These fatty acids have anti-inflammatory effects, which can help dislodge kidney stones and help prevent urinary tract infections.
  • Skin and Coat Health. Nutrients in pumpkin like zinc, vitamin E, and vitamin A are great for nourishing the skin and coat of your dog.
  • Parasite Control. Pumpkin contains an amino acid called cucurbitacin, which is toxic to many common dog parasites like tapeworm and ringworm.
  • Healthy Weight. The high fiber content in pumpkin is a highly satiating food. Fiber is undigestible but makes your dog feel full sooner and longer and helps to prevent overeating.

The Best Pumpkin Dog Treats Reviewed

There are different types of pumpkin dog treats on the market. To help you find the right ones for your dog, we have reviewed several options.

The Honest Kitchen Pumpkin and Cinnamon Goat’s Milk N’ Cookies

The Honest Kitchen Pumpkin and Cinnamon Goat’s Milk N’ Cookies

Get it on Amazon      Get it on The Honest Kitchen

Summary: These treats are the perfect mixture of goat’s milk, whole grains, and superfoods like pumpkin, honey, and coconut. They are packed with probiotics and prebiotics, thus supporting gut health, digestion, and intestinal motility. The ingredients are mixed and then baked in small batches. The Honest Kitchen does not use fillers, by-products, GMOs, and artificial preservatives. 

Flavor Options: Pumpkin; Blueberries & Vanilla; Peanut Butter & Honey 

Price: $9.99/8 oz 

Pros

  • Slow-baked, crunchy, and nutritious 
  • Packed with probiotics & prebiotics 
  • Whole-grain and wheat-free recipe 
  • Support gut health and digestion 
  • Made in small batches

Cons

  • No significant cons 

Ingredient Analysis: The ingredient list includes whole grains such as barley and rolled oats mixed with superfoods like real goat’s milk, pumpkin, honey, and coconut oil. Plus, it has dried Bacillus coagulans fermentation product for gut health. To boost the flavor, the formula features cinnamon and vanilla. The ingredients are preserved with mixed tocopherols (a natural preservative) and baked in small batches. 

Review: Dog owners are delighted with these crunchy and delicious treats for dogs. They say the treats smell great and are the perfect size for a reward. Overall, Amazon customers give the pumpkin dog treats 4.7 out of 5 stars. 

Fruitables Baked Pumpkin and Banana Treats

Fruitables Baked Pumpkin and Banana Treats

Get it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: These pumpkin dog treats are made with superfoods to provide high-quality nutrition. They are rich in antioxidants and contain only 8 calories per treat. The crunchy texture helps to clean teeth while the dog chews and provides an enjoyable treat eating experience. It is made in a large selection of flavors to fit the needs of any dog’s palate and is suitable for dogs of all life stages.

Best for: Dogs of all life stages

Flavor Options: Crispy Bacon and Apple; Pumpkin and Apple; Pumpkin and Banana; Pumpkin and Blueberry; Pumpkin and Cranberry; Sweet Potato and Pecan

Price: $0.68/oz

Pros

  • Wide selection of flavors
  • Only 8 kcal per treat
  • Rich in antioxidants
  • No corn or wheat
  • Made in the USA

Cons

  • Not a source of complete nutrition

Ingredient Analysis: Pumpkin oats, pearled barley, and potatoes are the primary ingredients in these treats. Each of these offers some vital nutrients like fiber, vitamin A and vitamin E. Cane molasses is used as a sweetener, while mixed tocopherols are included as a natural preservative. This is a simple and wholesome list of ingredients for a dog treat.

Review: Most consumers were happy to see their dogs get so excited about a treat. They were also pleased with the ingredients and the price of these pumpkin dog treats. Critical reviews, however, complained about poor quality control and poor customer service. Numerous shared images of treats were not molded into a shape; instead, they were just dough balls in a bag.

Blue Buffalo Health Bars Pumpkin and Cinnamon

Blue Buffalo Health Bars Pumpkin and Cinnamon

Get it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: Made with real pumpkin, these treats provide a taste dogs enjoy while giving them a healthy dose of vitamins and minerals. Wholesome ingredients are used in this formula that provides a clean and healthy taste and treats eating experience. It contains no poultry by-product meal, corn, wheat, or soy. These treats are available in a large variety of flavors and sizes and are suitable for dogs of all life stages.

Best for: Dogs of all life stages

Flavor Options: Apple & Yogurt; Bacon, Egg, & Cheese; Pumpkin & Cinnamon; Banana & Yogurt; Beef; Chicken Liver

Price: $0.30

Pros

  • A large variety of flavors to choose from
  • Made with wholesome grains
  • Fruits and vegetables offer vitamins and minerals
  • No corn, wheat, or soy
  • No artificial preservatives

Cons

  • Many customers complain this food made their dogs sick

Ingredient Analysis: Oatmeal and barley are the first two ingredients and offer healthy carbohydrates, while pumpkin and flaxseed give this treat its micronutrient profile. Cane molasses is used as a sweetener, and calcium, vitamin C, and vitamin E are added individually.

Review: Happy customers said their dog loves these pumpkin dog treats. They were happy with the reaction they got from their dogs when they gave these treats to them, and their dogs were delighted to receive them. Negative reviews cite things like this made their dog sick, the treats were dust when delivered, and they received an expired product when ordered on Amazon as reasons for their low ratings.

Grandma Lucy’s Organic Baked Pumpkin Dog Treat Recipe

Grandma Lucy's Organic Baked Pumpkin Dog Treat Recipe

Get it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: These vegan dog treats are USDA certified organic and certified Kosher. They are made with human-quality ingredients to be delicious and nutritious without artificial preservatives or flavors. These are free from hydrogenated oils and are easy to break into smaller pieces for smaller dogs or training exercises. They are only made in one taste and sold in one size package but are suitable for dogs of all ages.

Best for: Dogs of all life stages

Flavor Options: Pumpkin Recipe

Price: $1.08/oz

Pros

  • Vegan dog treat recipe
  • USDA organic and certified Kosher
  • Made with human-quality ingredients
  • Delicious and nutritious
  • No preservatives, fillers, and additives

Cons

  • Pumpkin is low on the ingredients list

Ingredient Analysis: Organic enriched wheat flour is the first ingredient, followed immediately but cane sugar. Pumpkin is put quite low on the ingredients list, indicating this is not a pumpkin heavy treat, therefore does not hold the same nutritional value as a real pumpkin. Overall, this is a slightly disappointing ingredients list for a pumpkin dog treat.

Review: This product has fewer reviews than some others on this list, but they are mostly highly rated reviews. Pet owners of all species, from hamsters to dogs, say their pets love these pumpkin dog treats, even their picky eaters. Critics complain about the added cane sugar and are concerned it isn’t safe for their dogs to consume.

Crafted by Humans Loved by Dogs Pumpkin Dog Treat Recipe

Crafted by Humans Loved by Dogs Pumpkin Dog Treat Recipe

Get it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: Baked exclusively with natural ingredients, this formula never uses anything artificial. The 100% human-grade ingredients make these dog biscuits highly digestible and easily breakable for training and for small dogs. There are no GMOs, BHA, BHT, or artificial colors in this limited ingredient dog treat. Each flavor uses no more than seven ingredients, and these treats are available in a variety pack to suit the taste of almost any dog.

Best for: Dogs of all life stages

Flavor Options: Bacon; Gingerbread; Pumpkin

Price: $1.89/oz

Pros

  • Gluten-free and grain-free
  • Human-grade foods
  • Made with non-GMO ingredients
  • Limited ingredient recipe
  • Fit for dogs with sensitive tummies

Cons

  • More expensive than similar options

Ingredient Analysis: There are only a handful of ingredients in this dog treat formula. Garbanzo bean flour, pumpkin, peanut butter, molasses, and cinnamon. None of these raise any red flags or causes for concern, and overall, this is a great ingredients list for a dog treat.

Review: Most consumers were thrilled with the ingredients list. Their pets love the pumpkin dog treats, and they are happy to give them to them. Some customers complained the price was too high for the package size although they agree the ingredients are great. Some others complained the dog biscuits were too small before they complained about the price, which equals 30-40 cents per biscuit.

Three Dog Bakery Baked Pumpkin Dog Treats Wafer

Three Dog Bakery Baked Pumpkin Dog Treats Wafer

Get it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: These dog treat wafers are grain-free and made with all-natural ingredients for premium flavor and nutrition. The soft-baked cookie recipe of these treats is perfect for puppies, seniors, and every dog in between to chew and digest quickly. They are made in the USA and packed with ingredients like pumpkin, cinnamon, and potato flour to become everything a dog needs in a treat. They are available in a small selection of flavors and sizes but are suitable for dogs of all life stages.

Best for: Dogs of all life stages

Flavor Options: Peanut Butter and Banana; Pumpkin; Sweet Potato

Price: $0.61/oz

Pros

  • Grain-free
  • No artificial flavors
  • Soft baked for dogs of all ages
  • Made in the USA
  • With only real ingredients

Cons

  • Pumpkin is far down the ingredients list

Ingredient Analysis: Tapioca starch, pea starch, and glycerin are the first ingredients and are wholesome sources of carbohydrates. Canola oil helps to provide fats and flavor, while dried pumpkin and cane molasses offer taste and vitamins.

Review: Satisfied customers were happy their dogs liked this treat, with many claiming this has become their dogs’ new favorite thing to eat. In fact, almost every high rating simply says their dog loves these treats. Dissatisfied customers complained about the pumpkin dog treats being too hard and not soft baked like advertised, and the biscuits became moldy shortly after opening the package.

Wag Expedition Human Grade Pumpkin and Chia Seed Dog Treats

Wag Expedition Human Grade Pumpkin and Chia Seed Dog Treats

Get it on Amazon

Summary: The human-grade ingredients in these dog treats give them wholesome nutrition in a safe, easily-digestible package. These treats are rich in omega-3 fatty acids and vitamin B6 for healthy skin and coat and proper brain function. The rich fiber content aids digestion in any of the flavors of these treats. They are organic, nom-GMO dog biscuits available in 5 flavors and made a great option for dogs of all ages.

Best for: Dogs of all life stages

Flavor Options: Pumpkin & Chia Seed; Banana & Coconut; Sunflower Seed Butter; Sweet Potato & Flaxseed 

Price: $0.60/oz

Pros

  • Human-grade ingredients
  • Rich in vitamin B6 and omega fatty acids
  • Dietary fiber for healthy digestion
  • Organic and nicely textured
  • High protein content for a dog treat

Cons

  • Often out of stock on online retailers

Ingredient Analysis: Organic lentil flour and buckwheat flour are the first ingredients and provide most of the carbs in this formula. Cane molasses is next, followed by pumpkin, and for a pumpkin dog treat, this seems odd. Apple cider vinegar is added for vitamins and helps to make this a healthy dog treat.

Review: The top positive reviews all claim this product smells and tastes great. Their dogs like the pumpkin dog treats, and the owners enjoy giving them to them because they like them. Most of the negative reviews are from people saying their dog just wouldn’t eat the treats or did not like them once they did.

Cloud Star Wag More Bark Less Grain-Free Pumpkin Crunchy Dog Treats

Cloud Star Wag More Bark Less Grain-Free Pumpkin Crunchy Dog Treats

Get it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: The homemade style of these dog treats offers seven simple and clean ingredients. They are grain-free and minimally processed dog biscuits that contain no wheat, corn, or soy. Each flavor is baked in the USA into different shapes to keep your dog entertained from treat to treat. It is suitable for dogs of all life stages and available in various flavors, so almost any dog can enjoy them.

Best for: Dogs of all life stages

Flavor Options: Chicken & Sweet Potato; Pumpkin; Peanut Butter & Apples; Smooth Aged Cheddar

Price: $0.57/oz

Pros

  • Made in the USA
  • Available in a variety of flavors
  • Made with only seven ingredients
  • No corn or wheat
  • No artificial preservatives

Cons

  • Relatively high in calories

Ingredient Analysis: There are only seven ingredients in these dog treats. Chickpea flour, pumpkin, flaxseed, pea flour, tapioca starch, canola oil, and mixed tocopherols. All of these are safe sources of nutrients for dogs.

Review: Satisfied customers were happy these treats were made in the USA, and their dog enjoys eating them. However, even five-star reviews noted this pumpkin dog treats often constipate their furry friends. Negative remarks make up almost 10% of total reviews, and most of the complaints said the treats just broke apart too easily.

PetLab Co. Salmon Bites for Dogs
9/10Our Score
  • Contains minerals and vitamins, perfect for promoting your dog's overall health
  • Has a delightful salmon flavor
  • Performs great wonders for your dog’s gut, skin, and coat health
  • Made using high-quality ingredients from the US and prime locations worldwide

How do You Make Homemade Pumpkin Dog Treats?

There are many recipes for pumpkin dog treats. Here is one of our favorites.

Ingredients:

  • 2 ½ cups whole wheat flour
  • 2 large eggs
  • ½ cup pumpkin puree/canned pumpkin (plain)
  • 2 tbsp peanut butter (xylitol-free)
  • ½ teaspoon salt
  • ½ teaspoon ground cinnamon

Instructions:

  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees F
  • Combine the ingredients in a large bowl
  • Transfer them from the mixing bowl to a lightly floured surface
  • Knead the mixture with your hands until it starts to come together
  • Roll the dough with a rolling pin to a thickness of 1/2 an inch
  • Cut out shapes using a cookie cutter (you can use a bone cookie cutter for extra fun)
  • Place them on a baking sheet on top of parchment paper
  • Bake the pumpkin dog treats until golden brown (exact cook time can vary).

Each pumpkin & peanut butter dog treat contains about 56 calories (fat 1.3g, cholesterol 14.9mg, sodium 62.9mg, carbohydrates 9.4g, and protein 2.5g). The overall prep time is less than an hour. After making the pumpkin peanut treats, you can store them in an airtight container.

Any pumpkin dog treat recipe can work as long as it does not contain ingredients that are harmful to dogs. Things with regular flour or all-purpose flour, oat flour, pureed pumpkin, and some spices can be used to make homemade dog treats.

When making pumpkin dog treats, use fresh pumpkin or plain pumpkin puree. It is imperative that you avoid pumpkin pie filling. This is because pumpkin pie fillings often contain added sugars such as xylitol (as this sweetener is toxic to dogs) and additional spices that can be harmful to dogs.

PetLab Co. Digestive Support Bites - Turkey Flavor
9/10Our Score
  • Provides nutritional support for a healthy gut, skin, and coat
  • Effective and tasty
  • Made with powerful ingredients such as organic apple cider vinegar and pumpkin 
  • A hefty source of vitamins A, C, and E, hence strengthening your dog's natural defenses 

Do Vets Recommend Pumpkin Dog Treats?

Yes, veterinarians recommend pumpkin dog treats.

They are often a great digestive aid and are low-calorie, so it can actually be challenging to overfeed dogs with pumpkin treats. Plus, they are loaded with health-boosting nutrients. Finally, pumpkin treats are readily available and easy to make at home.