What Are the Best Rubber Dog Toys?

MewaJump Durable Rubber Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers
  • The shape of the cactus makes the dog more excited, it is suitable for small dog, medium and large breed. There is also a unique milk flavor that makes dogs fall in love with cleaning his teeth.
  • Made of absolutely safe natural rubber. Its flexibility and bite resistance have been greatly improved. Long lasting support for large or heavy chewers.
  • It is also a dental cleaning toy, which can fully reduce dental plaque and gum bleeding caused by eating problems. 

Are Rubber Toys Okay for Dogs?

Yes, rubber dog toys are okay. They provide dogs with something to chew on to work their jaw muscles as well as stimulate blood flow to the dog’s gums. Rubber dog toys like Kongs and Nylabones are great for dental health and to help your dog benefit from the mental stimulation that comes from chewing.

Is a Rubber Ball Good for Dogs?

Yes, a rubber ball is good for dogs. Most rubber balls float to give dogs a water activity, but not all dogs enjoy swimming. For these dogs, a rubber ball dog toy can simply be something to chew on, especially for super chewers who have a hard time keeping toys intact.

Other fetch balls, like tennis balls, may not hold up against a dog’s chewing, but a rubber ball, like a chuck-it ball, may be able to. Additionally, rubber balls help alleviate stress and anxiety and limit destructive behavior.

What Kind of Rubber is Used in Dog Toys?

Thermoplastic rubber (TPR) is often used in small dog toys and puppy toys for teething. Its texture is great for soothing sore gums.

Latex rubber is also used as a safe, non-toxic alternative that can be stuffed with sponge cotton or a squeaker. This type of rubber is often thinner and more likely to tear than other types of rubber, though, and this should be accounted for when searching for durable rubber dog toys.

Whatever rubber is used in your dog’s toys, make sure it is free of BPAs, phthalates, and other hazardous chemicals. According to PetMD, these chemical bonds are “a group of chemicals also sometimes called “plasticizers,” which the CDC explains make plastics more flexible.” These can have detrimental effects on the dogs’ health.

What Are the Benefits of Rubber Dog Toys?

Physical and mental stimulation are some of the benefits of rubber dog toys. Here is a closer look at the pros of getting your dog rubber dog toys.

  • Mental Stimulation: Chewing activates and excites a dog’s brain. Toys, a dog treat dispenser or rubber tug toy, give the dog something to focus on, and this forces their brain to think differently and complete the task of chewing on a given item.
  • Instinct Support: Many rubber toys have squeakers and squawkers in them that mimic the noises of prey. This helps to engage a dog’s hunting instincts and brings them closer to their wild side.
  • Physical Exercise: Rubber fetch toys like rubber balls, and Nerf dog toys are fantastic for exercising your dog. The act of running to retrieve an item is some of the best physical exertions your dog can experience, but chewy rubber toys are also great options.

The Best Rubber Dog Toys Reviewed

The world of rubber dog toys is rich – there are many dog toy brands and types of rubber toys. To help you choose the best rubber dog toys, we reviewed some of the market’s best-sellers.

MewaJump Durable Rubber Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers

Price: $11.96

Toy Type: Rubber dog toys

Pet: Dogs

Lifestage: All life stages

Recommended Uses: Offer to your dog when they seem bored or stressed. Supervision is recommended when your dog is chewing on this toy.

Material: Rubber

Summary: The size and shape of this rubber dog toy are perfect for dogs of all sizes. The textured rubber helps to remove plaque from a dog’s teeth and encourages blood flow to their gums. The milk scent helps to keep dogs chewing for long periods to get all of the benefits this toy has to offer.

The natural rubber this toy is made of is safe and non-toxic to dogs. It is made to stand up to and provide support to heavy chewers during playtime. It is available in two colors and one size that is suitable for dogs of all sizes.

Pros
  • Milk scented
  • Lightweight and easy for dogs to carry
  • Cleans teeth while they chew
  • Helps to curb destructive behavior
  • Reduces stress and boredom
Cons
  • Does not have a squeaker
  • Does not float

Customer Reviews: Most of the 7,000+ customer reviews on Amazon raved about how durable, and tough this rubber toy was against their dog’s heavy chewing. Several went as far as to call it “indestructible” as their large dogs were not able to chew it apart.

Common complaints came from dog owners who were put off by the “harsh chemical” smell of the toy when it was new, and others said their dogs were able to chew off parts of the toy.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving MewaJump Durable Rubber Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers an overall 9/10-star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below

  • Pet Suitability (8/10): This toy is great for aggressive chewers but is not the best option for staple dog games like fetch.
  • Material Quality (8/10): Most buyers had no complaints about the durability of this dog chew, and neither do we. It seems to hold up strong to chewing.
  • Cost Effectiveness (8/10): This is about an average price for dog chews, although there are far more expensive options out there as well.
  • Customer Feedback (9/10): Thousands of reviews were left on this toy, and most enjoyed it, but more than a few of them raise legitimate concerns about their dog chewing and eating the material.
  • Care and Cleanability (9/10): It can be washed if necessary and requires no care or maintenance.
  • Product Variety (8/10): There are two colors available and one size option.
Aipper Puppy Chew Toys for Fun and Teeth Cleaning

Price: $17.58

Toy Type: Rubber dog toys, Ropes & Plushies 

Pet: Dogs

Lifestage: All life stages

Recommended Uses: Determine your dog’s preferred playing style and offer them toys relevant to that. If your dog prefers tug-of-war, offer them a rope toy or the squeaking squirrel. If they prefer to fetch, throw them one of the included balls, and if they are more food and treat-oriented, then the treat dispenser will likely be your best bet.

Material: Cotton; Plastic; Rubber

Summary: Assorted toy packages are a great way to bring new life to your dog’s home. In this pack, access to tugging ropes, treat dispensers, and waste bags are all included to help make dogs’ lives easier. All ingredients are made non-toxic and safe for dogs to play with.

The nylon ropes in this set are specific to tug-of-war except for the rope frisbee, which is great for fetch as well as a good game of tug. The dental toys are the blue rubber spiky bone and ball treat dispenser that gives dogs treat as they chew on the spikes. All in all, this toy set has everything new dog owners and owners of multiple dogs would need.

Pros
  • Fabric toys are machine washable
  • Squeakers, tugging ropes, and rubber chew toys
  • Geared toward dental care for dogs
  • Includes dog waste bags
  • Great for houses with multiple dogs
Cons
  • Few ratings give us a clear picture of what to expect from this toy pack
  • The rubber bone can be rather aggressive for the gums of young or small dogs

Customer Reviews: Fewer than 700 reviews have been written on Amazon about this toy set but only about 5% are critical of the set. The overall value of the pack was the key point of satisfaction with dog owners. They liked the options available to them and said their dog’s favorite toys are durable and have lasted them a long time.

Critical reviews almost invariably harped on the quality and said the toys did not withstand their dog’s chewing.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Aipper Puppy Chew Toys for Fun and Teeth Cleaning an overall 9/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below

  • Pet Suitability (9/10): There is something in this pack for every dog, but not all toys are made with the same quality.
  • Material Quality (7/10): Most toys were well made, but a few were a bit cheap and required constant supervision to prevent swallowing.
  • Cost Effectiveness (10/10): The assorted rubber dog toys in this affordable package would cost significantly more if bought individually.
  • Customer Feedback (6/10): Fewer than 700 reviews have been written on this toy set, but only around 5% are critical or negative.
  • Care and Cleanability (9/10): These toys require no cleaning, but they can be lost and broken easily.
  • Product Variety (10/10): There are 20 rubber dog toys in each toy set.
Chiwava Squeaky Standing Stick Animal Latex Dog Toys

Price: $14.98

Toy Type: Squeaky rubber dog toys 

Pet: Dogs

Lifestage: All life stages

Recommended Uses: Give these toys to your dog when they are feeling bored or anxious. This is a great toy to give them when they are unsupervised, as the high-pitched squeaking can become irritating over time.

Material: Non-toxic latex rubber

Summary: This FDA-approved latex rubber dog toy is safe for hard chewing and biting. It squeaks with each bite to encourage healthy chewing and blood flow to the jaws and muscles around the skull. This chewing action rubs the dog’s teeth against the toy, and this helps to loosen plaque and keep gums strong and healthy.

Each of the three toys in this pack is made of safe, non-toxic latex rubber. This rubber is FDA CFR 21 approved, so it is safe for your dog to enjoy for long periods of time. It is suitable for dogs up to 65 pounds and as small as 8 pounds, so most dogs can enjoy them.

Pros
  • Squeaker
  • 3 in one pack
  • No stuffing to create a mess
  • FDA approved
  • Suitable for small and medium dogs
Cons
  • Numerous customers complain their dog vomited after playing with these
  • It is not stated where these toys are manufactured

Customer Reviews: These durable dog toys received praise for their durability, and their dogs seem to enjoy gnawing on them. They also liked that they received three in a package and said for this price, it was well worth it.

Critical reviews expressed suspicion of a toxic coating on the toys. These reviews said their dogs vomited or whined constantly after playing with these toys.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Chiwava Squeaky Standing Stick Animal Latex Dog Toys an overall 7/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below

  • Pet Suitability (7/10): While we noticed no issues, many reviews stated their dog became ill after chewing on these.
  • Material Quality (7/10): The squeaker is quick to stop squeaking, but the rubber material is good for light chewers.
  • Cost Effectiveness (9/10): Three toys come in this pack, and each average right at $5.00, which is fairly inexpensive for dog chew toys.
  • Customer Feedback (8/10): Nearly 6,000 reviews have been done about this product, and just under 10% of them are critical or negative.
  • Care and Cleanability (7/10): These rubber dog toys can be hand washed but keeping the toys in mint condition is nearly impossible.
  • Product Variety (9/10): There are three rubber toys in each package, but there is only one option for which package you can purchase.
Charming Pet Latex Rubber Balloon Squeaky Dog Toy

Price: $8.29

Toy Type: Squeaky rubber dog toys 

Pet: Dogs

Lifestage: All life stages

Recommended Uses: Give this rubber squeaker to your dog when they are bored or at the end of the day to give them something to work their jaw muscles and encourage healthy chewing.

Material: Rubber

Summary: Squeaky toys are a must-have for most dog owners. This natural latex rubber dog toy is tough against chewing and can be used for any kind of game. It is a great fetch toy as well as a chew toy.

The rubber this toy is made of is lead and phthalate-free, making it non-toxic and safe for your dog. Multiple styles and sizes are available to suit the preferences of nearly any dog and a dog owner.

Pros
  • Features a fun squeaker
  • Great for large dogs
  • Available in multiple shapes and sizes
  • Suitable for all types of play
  • Lead and phthalate-free
Cons
  • Some shapes can pose choking hazards
  • Recent reviews complain about a change in the materials that made it less durable

Customer Reviews: Some of the shapes this toy is available in have parts that can be chewed off and pose a choking hazard. This concerned some buyers, and they cautioned others to be aware of this in their reviews.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Charming Pet Latex Rubber Balloon Squeaky Dog Toy an overall 8/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below

  • Pet Suitability (9/10): The squeaking action and rubber makeup of this toy are great for most dogs, but not all dogs will be interested in it.
  • Material Quality (9/10): The rubber is safe, non-toxic, and durable against light and moderate chewers.
  • Cost Effectiveness (6/10): This is the average price rubber dog toys of this type and size.
  • Customer Feedback (6/10): Just over 1,800 reviews have been written about this product, and these ratings give this product a relatively high average rating of 4.6 stars.
  • Care and Cleanability (8/10): There is no cleaning or care required for this toy, but it can be washed by hand if dirty.
  • Product Variety (5/10): There are no other options available at this time for this toy, but the toy itself serves multiple play styles well.
Multipet's Latex Polka Dot Globken Chicken Dog Toy

Price: $5.32

Toy Type: Squeaky rubber dog toys 

Pet: Dogs

Lifestage: Adult dogs

Recommended Uses: Offer to your adult dog to keep them entertained during lulls or when relaxing. Puppies who are teething will likely not receive the best benefits from this toy.

Material: Latex rubber

Summary: These rubber chickens are the perfect interactive toys for your dog or puppy. They feature a fun and colorful polka-dotted latex design with a plush filling that your furry friends will love. These vibrant-colored chickens squeak when squeezed, providing the best interactive play.

Each toy is made of non-toxic rubber and is filled with a cotton sponge. This gives the toy responsiveness when chewed on that dogs love. The squeaker helps to encourage firm biting and mimics prey to entice the dog’s hunting instincts.

Pros
  • Plush filled
  • Squeaks and squawks
  • Made in various colors
  • Great for big dogs
  • Great at reducing destructive chewing
Cons
  • Multiple color choices are available but are shipped at random; customers cannot choose the color
  • May be too big for most small-breed dogs

Customer Reviews: Over 85% of reviews were positive. These reviews stated the toy was of high quality and said their dogs love the toy. Owners of small and big dogs alike say this rubber chicken is their dog’s new favorite toy.

The most common complaint, by far, was the quality of the toy presenting a choking hazard. Customers posted photos with their reviews to show the damage their dogs had done to the toy to display their point.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving Multipet’s Latex Polka Dot Globken Chicken Dog Toy an overall 8/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below

  • Pet Suitability (9/10): Not all dogs will be interested in playing with these rubber dog toys, but most will likely be intrigued by them.
  • Material Quality (9/10): The latex rubber is lead and phthalate-free, but it can be torn easily.
  • Cost Effectiveness (9/10): This is a great price for a rubber dog toy.
  • Customer Feedback (10/10): Nearly 10,000 reviews give this toy an average of 4.5 stars, with less than 10% of ratings being critical of the product.
  • Care and Cleanability (9/10): These rubber dog toys are easy to care for and are effectively maintenance-free.
  • Product Variety (5/10): Although various colors are available, only the seller gets to choose what color you receive.
PWEITUOET Rubber Squeaky Dog Toys for Small Dog

Price: $13.99

Toy Type: Squeaky rubber dog toys 

Pet: Small dogs

Lifestage: Puppies

Recommended Uses: Offer to your adult dog to keep them entertained during lulls or when relaxing. Puppies who are teething will likely not receive the best benefits from this toy.

Material: Rubber

Summary: The safe natural rubber this toy is made of is durable and great for small dogs. Vibrant colors make these toys easy to find when they are lost, and the massaging texture of each toy is great for stimulating a dog’s gums. This toy is made of 100% safe and non-toxic latex rubber.

The long body of this toy fits perfectly in the mouths of small dogs and puppies. The squeaker provides them with fun and excitement as they play and keeps their attention. Supervision is recommended when this toy is in use as it is not meant to stand up to heavy chewing.

Pros
  • Suitable for small dogs
  • Squeaker
  • Brightly colored, so it is easy to find
  • Retains shape well
  • Safe latex rubber construction
Cons
  • Not for aggressive chewers
  • Fewer than 200 reviews have been written, so we do not have a clear expectation of this product

Customer Reviews: Reviews were sparse, but they were mostly positive. People liked how loud and bouncy these toys were as their small and medium dogs played with them all over the house.

Lower ratings did not like the quality of the toy and said they emitted a “funky smell” even after multiple washes.

Veterinarians.org Review: Our team at veterinarians.org is giving PWEITUOET Rubber Squeaky Dog Toys for Small Dog an overall 8/10 star rating. A breakdown of our rating is listed below

  • Pet Suitability (9/10): Squeaky toys are great for most dogs, and the variety of toys in this package gives dogs options.
  • Material Quality (8/10): These rubber dog toys would be great for most small dogs, but some will be able to destroy them quickly.
  • Cost Effectiveness (9/10): Each toy in this pack costs just over $4.00, which is lower than the average price for a rubber squeaking dog toy.
  • Customer Feedback (5/10): Fewer than 200 reviews have been written about this dog toy.
  • Care and Cleanability (9/10): These toys are easily cleaned by hand.
  • Product Variety (9/10): No options are available, but each package has three different toys of assorted colors.

What Should I Look for in a Rubber Dog Toy?

When shopping for rubber dog toys, consider the following factors.

  • Type of Rubber: Make sure the rubber your dog’s toys are made of is BPA-free and phthalate-free to avoid any threat of serious health complications. Rubber dog toys with these chemicals pose a serious health danger.
  • Toy Type: Rubber dog toys come in different designs – from balls and water toys to squeaker toys and interactive toys. Choose the type of toy your dog is most likely to enjoy. For example, if your dog is prone to anxiety, get a stuffable rubber toy that can be filled with peanut butter.
  • Size: It is also important to get the right toy size. If the toy is too big, your dog will not be able to play with it, and if too small, it poses a choking hazard. To ensure the right fit, many rubber dog toys come in different sizes – toys for small dogs and toys for large dogs.
  • Brand: Pay attention to the brand. Reputable brands will be transparent about the type of rubber used in the toy and have positive reviews from other customers. Also, USA-based brands offer dog toys of higher quality than brands from China.

What Happens if a Dog Eats a Rubber Toy?

If a dog happens to ingest some of the rubber from its toys, the best course of action is always to consult with a veterinarian immediately. These can cause blockages in the digestive tract that can be life-threatening.

Most often, though, when a dog swallows a bit of rubber, it will pass through them naturally. Still, it is not a chance dog owners should be willing to take if they can afford to get their dog to the vet at a time like this.