Ttwo,Cute,Tabby,Cats,Eating,Together,Dry,Food,From,A

Smalls Cat Food Reviewed: Pros, Cons, and Ingredient Analysis

Charles Grisham
By Charles Grisham
Medically reviewed by Ivana Crnec, DVM
If you buy something from a link on our site, we may earn a commission. See our advertising disclosure.
If you buy something from a link on our site, we may earn a commission.
See our advertising disclosure.

Smalls Cat Food Summary

  • Smalls Cat Food is a subscription pet food delivery service that sends pet food to your doorstep regularly each month and is not sold in grocery stores.
  • Smalls offers dog food and cat food in raw, freeze-dried raw, and kibble food varieties, all of which are made with human-grade ingredients that are ethically and sustainably sourced.
  • Smalls has numerous formulas: the Smalls Fresh Bird Recipe, Fresh Other Bird Recipe, Fresh Cow Recipe, Freeze-Dried Raw Turkey Recipe, Freeze-Dried Fish Kibble Recipe, Raw Water Bird, Fresh Other Bird, and Freeze-Dried Raw Bird Recipe.

What is Smalls Cat Food?

Smalls Cat Food is pet food made from real, raw ingredients like chicken, chicken liver, and gizzard to provide the appropriate protein content a carnivore needs.

Smalls adds herring oil for fat and sweet potatoes for carbohydrates, and all of their ingredients are humanely harvested and sustainably sourced. It uses limited ingredients to make frozen and freeze-dried raw cat food.

Where is Smalls Cat Food Made?

Smalls Cat Food is made in Chicago, IL, USA.

How is Smalls Cat Food Made?

It is made with sustainably sourced ingredients. They freeze their food raw or freeze-dry their food after gently cooking it to make it safe for animal consumption.

Smalls freeze-dried and frozen ingredients are minimally processed to be turned into frozen raw food and raw kibble, but they do not make typical dry food. They use things like chicken breast and ground beef as the foundation for their recipes and add green beans and potatoes for carbs and fiber before they form it into one of two available textures: frozen raw and freeze-dried raw. Their basic production process is chop, steam, and freeze.

The first step is to mince the ingredients so they can be formed into kibble or packaged after being frozen. The ingredients are steam-cooked gently and then frozen to lock in nutrients. From there, it is shipped to cat owners for their cats to enjoy.

Is Smalls Cat Food Good for Cats?

Yes, Smalls Cat Food is good.

Their use of raw ground chicken, beef, and turkey in their cat food recipes is key to the nutrition they provide pets. They only use human-grade ingredients to ensure your pet is receiving high-quality ingredients, and they formulate a meal plan for your pet with a questionnaire at the beginning of the process.

All of this is put in place so you can be sure when you receive Smalls products, you are receiving high-end food options from a high-quality cat food brand. The use of raw ingredients may even help alleviate some health issues.

Their freeze-dried foods are healthy options, although Smalls recommends adding human-grade raw foods to ensure a complete nutritional profile.

Pros
  • Human-grade ingredients and USDA-certified recipes
  • Fresh food with high-quality and sustainable proteins
  • High protein, low carb formula
  • Four different tastes and two textures
  • No artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives
  • Polite customer service and home delivery option
Cons
  • Needs freezer-storing and thawing before use
  • Not individually portioned
  • Available only via subscription

Smalls Cat Food Reviewed

Since there are various Smalls formulas for cats, we will take a look at some recipes and their basic features.

Smalls Cat Food Formulas:

About Smalls Cat Food:

Smalls cat food is a subscription service costing anywhere from $30-$130 per month, depending on your subscription level. They use only real, raw meat and ingredients that are either frozen or freeze-dried to lock in the natural nutrient density of the food. Their headquarters are in New York, and their food is produced in Chicago in a USDA-certified facility.

What’s in a Smalls Cat Food Subscription Box:

After completing the questionnaire, you will receive a sampler to decide what formulas will work best for your pet. After deciding what product you want and officially signing up for the service, you will begin to receive regularly scheduled packages.

Inside a Smalls pet food subscription box, you will receive their fresh or freeze-dried food product or products for your dog or cat and any toys, treats, or litter you choose to add to your subscription. Using code “catconcierge” will save you 33% on your first order.

Smalls Cat Food Pros:

  • Whole Food Ingredients. Small uses only whole foods in their products, never any additives or fillers. They use minimal processing production to form their wet food into high-protein foods without preservatives in each of their formulas.
  • Guaranteed Analysis. While many cat food brands offer a guaranteed analysis of their food, Smalls offers a more in-depth analysis. They even include vitamin and mineral breakdowns, so you know exactly what your cat is eating.
  • Subscription Service. The food is sent to your door each month so obtaining cat food is a simple and relatively mindless task.
  • Human-Grade Foods. Smalls uses human-grade ingredients to make their pet foods. This means they use food people can safely consume to formulate their products.
  • Money-Back Guarantee. Smalls offers a 100% money-back guarantee if not satisfied during the risk-free trial.

Smalls Cat Food Cons:

  • Purchasing. You must go through the entire purchasing process of inputting information about your cat, entering your email address, and heading to the checkout screen to see what the actual cost of their recommendation for you will be. In fact, if you click any link from a site other than smalls.com, you will be routed directly to their questionnaire page to begin the process of signing up for their service. Their prices are opaque until the last minute, at which time you will have been put on their mailing list. This can be annoying to some people just exploring good food options for their pets.
  • Cost. Your cat needs high-quality nutrition, and Smalls offers that but at a relatively high price. So, if you are on a budget, this brand might not be the best choice.

Smalls Cat Food Reviews:

Reviews of Smalls and their products are outstanding. Almost anywhere you look, you will find 8, 9, and 10-star reviews raving about their products and their services.

These reviews often cite free sampler packs, ethical sourcing of ingredients, and the ability to edit, skip, or cancel your subscription at any time as the reason for such high remarks. We couldn’t find critical reviews that expressed dissatisfaction with anything except the price, and even that wasn’t enough to dissuade many reviewers from giving it a 10/10 score.

How does Smalls Cat Food Work?

Smalls has you fill out an introduction form of several questions regarding your pet.

  • Step 1: Click “get started,” and you will be directed to a page that says “choose recipes.” There you will click “get started” and go to a page asking you for your pet quantity.
  • Step 2: Enter the number of pets for which you are buying food and their name, then click “next.”
  • Step 3: Here, you will identify the gender of your cat as well as the age and whether or not they are spayed or neutered. Then click ”next.”
    They will then ask you if you are looking for an age-specific food. You are not required to answer the question, it is just an opportunity for them to remind you their food is good for cats of all ages.
  • Step 4: Choose your cat’s build from slender, average, to “extra cuddly.” Once you click “next,” you are taken to a page where they remind you Smalls is a good option for cats of all builds because of the nutrient content of their food.
  • Step 5: Select what meats your cat will not eat, then click “continue.”
  • Step 6: This is where they tell you what plan you will be on. They briefly explain their food is based on your cat’s biology, and from there, you will click “checkout now.”
  • Step 7: Here, you will have the chance to add anything to your subscription, like cat treats or toys.
  • Step 8: They present you with a special offer.
  • Step 9: This is where you enter your email address and shipping information. From here, you will click “continue to payment.”
  • Step 10: Here is where you find out what your subscription will cost and where you will enter your payment information.

Smalls 1

Smalls 2

Smalls 3

Smalls 4

Smalls 5

Smalls 6

Smalls 7

Smalls 8

Smalls 9

What Ingredients are in Smalls Cat Food?

The ingredients in Smalls pet products are all human-grade and come from ethical sources. They use things like chicken thigh, chicken breast, and chicken liver in the Smalls chicken recipes and turkey thigh and chicken liver in their other bird recipes.

Their beef recipes offer 90% lean beef, beef liver, and beef hearts. No meat goes unnamed in their recipes, you will not see a generic “liver” ingredient, and you will always know what kind of animal that liver came from.

Vegetables like green beans, kale, and peas are used for vitamins, carbs, and fiber. All of which are grown on organic and sustainable farms. They supplement their food with vitamins and minerals to fortify it with complete and balanced nutrition. All of this makes their food slightly higher in calories, but the ingredients are whole and natural. This means your cat will need to eat less of them to feel just as full.

You will never see artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives in their food, nor will you see feed-grade grains or things like guar gum and xanthan gum. Smalls keeps it as real as possible when it comes to the ingredients in their foods.

Human-Grade Fresh Chicken Recipes

Chicken

This is one of the most popular Smalls recipes. It is a high-protein fresh cat food made with fresh chicken breast and chicken heart and adds green beans for vitamins. Added vitamins make this a more complete nutritional food. We aren’t a fan of their use of vegetable oil as a fat additive.

Guaranteed analysis:

  • Chicken Thigh Skin On: 42.55%
  • Chicken Breast: 36.91%
  • Chicken Livers: 4.70%
  • Green Beans: 3.77%

Human-Grade Fresh Beef Recipe

Beef

This recipe uses 90% lean ground beef, beef liver, and beef hearts for necessary vitamins and proteins. All of this is great, the only potential problem is the use of vegetables early on in the ingredients list.

Guaranteed analysis:

  • Ground Beef (90% Lean): 68.32%
  • Beef Liver: 6.64%
  • Green Beans: 5.69%
  • Beef Heart: 5.22%
  • Peas: 5.22%

Human-Grade Fresh Turkey Recipes

Turkey

This is made with turkey thigh as the primary ingredient and followed by chicken liver. Green beans are third, which is not generally ideal for meat-eaters. Every ingredient after chicken liver, in fact, is plant-based which may not be the healthiest option for some cats.

Guaranteed analysis:

  • Turkey Thigh (skin-on): 74.69%
  • Chicken Livers: 7.47%
  • Green Beans: 2.80%
  • Peas: 2.34%

Freeze-Dried Raw: Chicken

Freeze Dried Chicken

With turkey thigh, chicken liver, green beans, peas, and kale, it seems as though this recipe relies heavily on vegetables for nutritional value. This might not be ideal for cat health, but the vegetable content is relatively low, even though it is ranked highly in the ingredient list.

Guaranteed analysis:

  • Turkey Thigh (skin-on): 74.69%
  • Chicken Livers: 7.47%
  • Green Beans: 2.80%
  • Peas: 2.34%

Freeze-Dried Raw: Turkey

Freeze Dried Turkey

This recipe consists of freeze-dried raw turkey, turkey thigh, gizzard, and vegetables for vitamins and fiber. The nutrient profile is balanced even if there is a big reliance on vegetables for some micronutrients.

Guaranteed analysis:

  • Crude Protein (min): 49.0%
  • Crude Fat (min): 17.0%
  • Crude Fiber (max): 3.0%
  • Moisture (max): 8.0%

Freeze-Dried Raw: Duck

Freeze Dried Duck

Finely ground duck, duck heart, and duck gizzard are the bulk of this formula. These are all great sources of protein and minerals. Goat’s milk, herring oil, and duck egg are also used to add texture and more balanced nutrition. All of this together makes for a fantastic food made without the use of vegetables.

Guaranteed analysis:

  • Crude Protein (min): 45.0%
  • Crude Fat (min): 20.0%
  • Crude Fiber (max): 3.0%
  • Moisture (max): 8.0%

Has Smalls Cat Food Been Recalled?

Yes, Smalls Cat Food has been recalled in the past.

They have been recalled twice. Once in March 2019 and again in June 2021. In March 2019, certain packages of “Diamond Dust” chicken liver, powder were recalled from the supplier of the powder and this caused Smalls to recall the packages of food which used that ingredient. In 2021, they had refrigeration problems that may have contaminated the food as it is made without preservatives.

How much does a Smalls Subscription Cost?

A Smalls subscription will cost you between $30 and $130, depending on your subscription level.

Is Smalls Cat Food Worth it?

Yes, Smalls Cat Food is worth it as long as you can afford it.

Smalls offers human-grade foods for your pet made of whole prey ingredients. They do not skimp on their recipes, and their ingredients are responsibly sourced. So, when you are buying a Smalls product, you are supporting a company that is eco-conscious and self-aware.

Smalls is, however, a high-end pet food company, and the raw food options they provide can come at a steep price.

Smalls Cat Food
  • Smalls Human-Grade Fresh is protein-rich and picky cat-friendly. 
  • Our ingredients are USDA-certified, humanely-harvested, and sustainably-sourced—no BPAs, preservatives, fillers, or mystery-ingredients, ever.Smalls Freeze-Dried Raw retains the nutritional benefits of a raw, high-protein diet.