Temptations-Cat-Treats-Reviewed-Pros-Cons-and-Ingredient-Analysis

Temptations Cat Treats Reviewed: Pros, Cons, and Ingredient Analysis

Katelyn Son
By Katelyn Son
Medically reviewed by Ivana Crnec, DVM
If you buy something from a link on our site, we may earn a commission. See our advertising disclosure.
If you buy something from a link on our site, we may earn a commission.
See our advertising disclosure.

Temptations Cat Treats Summary

Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats
  • Your adult cat can’t wait to get their paws on these scrumptious cat food treats that are crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside
  • Under 2 calories per chicken flavor cat treat, so you can feel good about rewarding your cat every day
  • Temptations Cat Treats are 100% nutritionally complete and balanced for adult cat maintenance and can be used as a treat, meal, or cat food topper

What are Temptations Cat Treats Made of?

Temptations Cat Treats are made with simple ingredients and unique in their texture, with a crunchy outside and a soft inside. They are blended with essential nutrients and have less than two calories per piece.

Temptations Cat Treats is one of the most popular American cat treat brands. Temptations is owned by Mars Petcare, part of Mars, Incorporated, alongside other giants such as Whiskas, IAMS, Nutro, Greenies, Royal Canin, and Eukanuba.

Where are Temptations Cat Treats Made?

Temptations Cat Treats are made in the Mars Inc.-owned manufacturing facility at Bolton, Ontario, Canada.

How are Temptations Cat Treats Made?

Temptations Cat Treats have a protein-forward formula with salmon, chicken, tuna, shrimp, turkey, crab, and more. Each formula also contains added protein from meat by-products and animal fat. The processing of these formulas depends on the texture of the treat.

The original Temptations Cat Treats are popular for their dual texture. Overall, Temptations are protein-rich, savory treats processed to maximize the taste quotient of the products.

Are Temptations Treats Good for Cats?

Yes, Temptations Cat Treats are good.

Temptations have a large number of customers all over the world. This speaks for the popularity of the brand. Overall, Temptations Cat Treats seems like a good choice. The flavor profile is varied with many protein sources and specific formulas based on the dietary requirements of different cats.

Temptations Cat Treats Reviewed

This review will help you understand the pros and cons of the most popular Temptations Cat Treat formulas so that you can make an informed decision.

Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats

Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat TreatsGet it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: This is the original Temptations Treat formula for cats. This best-seller formula has the dual texture of crunchy on the outside and soft and chewy on the inside that cats love. This cat treat contains protein as the first and major ingredient, further boosted by niacin, taurine, and riboflavin supplements that are essential for feline health. Comes in a super value pack that will last for a long time.

Type: Dry treats

Best for: Adult cats

Flavor Options: Chicken, salmon, seafood, tuna, catnip

Price: N/A

Pros

  • Dual textured treats that make cats excited for treat times
  • Contains protein as the major ingredient
  • Has multiple flavor options with high-quality protein flavors
  • Contains riboflavin, taurine, and niacin, essential for feline health
  • Value for money product

Cons

  • Contains animal fat in the preservative as the second ingredient

Ingredient Analysis: The treats contain chicken by-product meal, ground corn, animal fat, rice, dried meat by-products, wheat flour, natural flavors, corn gluten meal, taurine, dried cheese, vitamins, and minerals.

Review: Based on 40,028 customer reviews, this Temptations chicken formula has an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. Pet owners state their cats are obsessed with this product.

Temptations Mixups Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats

Temptations Mixups Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats

Get it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: This formula also has the delectable dual texture of Temptations cat treats in  3 different flavors that cats love. This formula contains a balanced amount of protein, minerals, and essential vitamins that make up a 100% balanced meal. Moreover, each treat has less than two calories to help maintain your cat’s calorie count. Boosted with brewer’s yeast that helps in digestion. This formula is free of artificial flavors.

Type: Dry treats

Best for: Adult cats

Flavor Options: Chicken, catnip, cheddar cheese

Price: N/A

Pros

  • Three different protein-rich flavor
  • Dual texture of crunchy outside and chewy inside
  • Balanced formula with essential nutrients and vitamins
  • Improves digestion
  • Low-calorie treat that maintains a healthy weight

Cons

  • Contains animal fat in a preservative as the second ingredient

Ingredient Analysis: The ingredients in these treats include chicken by-product meal, ground corn, animal fat, dried meat by-products, brewers rice, wheat flour, catnip powder, natural flavor, grain distillers dried yeast, taurine, DL-methionine, shrimp meal, dried cheddar cheese, vitamins, and minerals.

Review: Based on the feedback from 47,693 customers, this tasty chicken flavor cat treat formula has an average of 4.8 out of 5 stars. Customers state that their cat loves this treat, and it can also be used to train their cats.

Temptations Jumbo Stuff Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats

Temptations Jumbo Stuff Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats

Get it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: A classic Temptations dual-textured cat treat in delicious salmon flavor that cats inherently love. This treat has protein as the first ingredient, balanced with minerals and vitamins for complete nutrition in each bite. This formula has less than two calories in every piece making this a healthy treat option. Enriched with thiamin, biotin, and riboflavin that enhance bone health, vision, and vitality in cats.

Type: Dry treats

Best for: Adult cats

Flavor Options: Salmon

Price: N/A

Pros

  • Dual textured treats that cats love
  • Protein is the major ingredient
  • Contains salmon as per feline dietary requirements
  • Less than two calories in each treat
  • Affordable and value for money

Cons

  • Contains animal fat in a preservative as the second ingredient

Ingredient Analysis: These treats contain chicken by-product meal, ground corn, animal fat, dried meat by-products, brewers rice, wheat flour, natural flavors, grain distillers dried yeast, caramel color, taurine, DL-methionine, natural tuna flavor, dried cheese, vitamins, and minerals

Review: Based on 16,141 customer reviews, this product has an average rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars. Customers state that their cats love this flavor, and even the pickiest eater cats cannot resist it.

Temptations ShakeUps Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats

Temptations ShakeUps Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats

Get it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: This range of treats by Temptations is targeted to provide a blend of savory flavors in the form of dual-textured treats that cats cannot deny. This treat formula has multiple protein sources like lobster, crab, and shrimp mixed into one treat for an umami bomb for your cat’s palate. This is a balanced treat formula with high crude protein followed by fiber and vitamins. Comes in a stay-fresh pack that ensures the goodness of fresh treats for your cat every time.

Type: Dry treats

Best for: Adult cats

Flavor Options: Shrimp, crab, chicken, lobster, turkey, beef, tuna

Price: N/A

Pros

  • Multiple protein sources blended into one
  • Dual textured treat granules
  • Balanced nutrition
  • Low calorie treats with less than two calories per treat
  • Boosts digestive health with brewer’s dry yeast

Cons

  • Contains animal fat in a preservative as the second ingredient

Ingredient Analysis: The ingredient list of these treats features chicken by-product meal, ground corn, animal fat, brewers rice, wheat flour, dried meat by-products, natural flavors, brewers dried yeast, salt, taurine, DL-methionine, dried cheese, vitamins, and minerals

Review: Based on 10,659 customer reviews, this beef flavor variety pack treat has an average rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars. Pet parents claim their cats will not touch any other treat after using these.

Temptations Creamy Puree Lickable Cat Treats

Temptations Creamy Puree Lickable Cat Treats

Get it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: A smooth and rich, creamy purrrr-ée treat that will keep your cat engaged in devouring it. Blended with delicious proteins like chicken, salmon, and tuna, this treat will keep your cat nourished as well as hydrated. Comes in single-serve pouches making treat times free of hassle or mess. Boosted with taurine, which improves coat and skin health in cats.

Type: Wet puree

Best For: Adult cats

Flavor Options: Chicken, salmon, tuna

Price: N/A

Pros

  • Creamy puree formulation
  • Easy to serve single pre-portioned packs
  • Keeps cats hydrated from inside
  • Improves skin and coat health
  • Available in variety packs

Cons

  • Contain gravy thickeners

Ingredient Analysis: The treats contain water, chicken liver, chicken by-product, chicken, pork liver, pork by-product, vegetable oil, glycine, tapioca starch, dried milk protein, xanthan gum, sodium carboxymethylcellulose, guar gum, cysteine, and taurine.

Review: Based on 1,837 customer reviews, this product with savory salmon flavor and tempting tuna flavor has an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars. Customers claim that their picky eater cats are happy with this creamy dairy flavor treat.

Temptations Meaty Bites Soft and Savory Cat Treats

Temptations Meaty Bites Soft and Savory Cat Treats

Get it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: A soft textured chewy treat formula for cats who like savory treats. This treat is made with 34% real protein from fresh salmon. Contains yeast extract that aids in the digestive health of cats. Enriched with taurine for improved skin and coat health. Comes in an affordable, value-for-money pack.

Type: Dry treats

Best for: Adult cats

Flavor Options: Salmon

Price: N/A

Pros

  • High protein blend with 34% real protein
  • Soft and chewy formula for easy consumption
  • Improves digestive health
  • Taurine promotes skin and coat health
  • Each treat portion has less than two calories.

Cons

  • Often out of stock on online retailers 

Ingredient Analysis: The treats contain salmon by-product, pork, pork liver, turkey, pork rind, brewers dried yeast, sugar, animal plasma, salt, yeast extract, vitamins, and minerals.

Review: Based on 140 customer feedback, this dry cat food has an average of 4.5 out of 5 stars. Customers claim that their feline friend loves the flavor and will not eat any other cat treat.

Temptations Classic Cat Treats

Temptations Classic Cat Treats

Get it on Amazon        Get it on Chewy

Summary: This is a classic formula of cat treat by Temptations. Filled with the goodness of real chicken on the inside and a crunchy outside provides the unique dual texture of Temptations treats for cats. This formula contains sustainably sourced ingredients, making this a climate pledge-friendly product. This formula is free of any artificial flavors. Boosted with essential nutrients (folic acid, taurine, vitamins, and minerals) that improve overall feline health.

Type: Dry treats

Best for: Adult cats

Flavor Options: Chicken

Price: N/A

Pros

  • Dual textured treats that cats love
  • Sustainably sourced ingredients
  • Free of artificial flavors
  • Contains essential nutrients that improve feline health
  • 100% nutritionally balanced formula

Cons

  • Contains animal fat in preservative as the second ingredients

Ingredient Analysis: The cat treats contain chicken by-product meal, ground corn, animal fat, rice, dried meat by-products, wheat flour, natural flavors, corn gluten meal, salt, taurine, DL-methionine, dried cheese, vitamins, and minerals.

Review: Based on the feedback from 337 customers, this crunchy treat has an average rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars. Customers claim that their cats love treat times and are excited about munching on these treats.

What are the Ingredients in Temptations Cat Treats?

Based on our in-depth analysis, the major ingredients in Temptations Cat Treats are as follows:

  • Chicken By-Product Meal. Contains a mix of chicken organs. This ingredient has an average nutritional value and doesn’t have any health benefits.
  • Ground Corn. Rich in fiber but carbohydrates and sugar as well. High content of ground corn is not ideal in any pet food formulation.
  • Animal Fat. Added to pet food to increase the caloric density of the formula. This provides energy to cats; however, it is high in fat content.
  • Rice. A healthy grain that is easy to digest and provides energy.
  • Dried Meat By-Products. Should ideally contain dried organs from different animals and provide energy and enzymes necessary for digestion.

What Cat Treat Formulas Does Temptations Make?

Temptations Cat Treats offers a range of delicious treats. Here is a list of the brand’s product lines and treat formulas:

How Many Temptations Cat Treats Can I Give My Cat a Day?

As per the manufacturer guidelines, the feeding instructions vary based on the formula type and your cat’s age and weight.

However, the rule of thumb is to give 10-12 pieces of the treat per 10lbs of your cat’s weight. In the case of wet treat formulas, provide no more than one pre-portioned serving a day to your cat.

What Happens If I Give Too Many Temptations Cat Treats?

If you end up giving your cat more Temptations treats than advised by the manufacturer, your cat will be at risk of developing obesity (due to high sugar and fat-based ingredients that take longer to digest in the gut); as well as stomach irritations (due to added flavors and preservatives in most of the formulas).

Thus, it is important to read the product details and stick to the manufacturer’s feeding guide at the back of each package.

How Long Do Temptations Cat Treats Last?

The classic dual-textured treats can last up to 1 year after the manufacturing date if unopened. If opened, they should be finished within a month and refrigerated in airtight containers while in use.

The wet cat treats should be used on the day of the opening (pre-portioned pouches for easy use). If unopened, the wet treats can last up to six months from the manufacturing date.

Have Temptations Cat Treats Been Recalled?

No, Temptations Cat Treats have not been recalled.